A Working Thesis

WGTB logo PNG 112x89 Post 50 in a series. When Green Turns Brown is an examination of a small town’s digester-energy project, in which Whitewater, Wisconsin would import other cities’ waste, claiming that the result would be both profitable and green.

This is the fiftieth post in this series, with many more to come, along with a standalone website to launch, related social media to support that website, and thereafter a written and video account of waste-hauling projects like the one Whitewater is undertaking.

A reader asked me over the weekend if I had a working thesis, or theme, after these posts. Well, I do, and a commenter’s remarks on a post from November (Questions on the 9.17.15 Remarks on Waste Importation) are a fair description of what a working perspective looks alike. Here’s Sue, commenting on a WGTB post from 11.17.15:

This idea won’t get better. It’s just pretending to say that other cities are rushing to do this. It’s a plan for down and outers. Towns do this because they have quit on themselves. It’s an idea for suckers, that’s all. A successful community of people who cared about their futures would never laugh the way the people in this room do. A successful community of people who cared about their families and property would not have thought the glowing children quip was funny. They wouldn’t hire the kind of person who thought that was funny. If someone showed a successful community the video no one would hire someone who said these things. Part of what you’re doing is showing people who care that they’ve settled for politicians who aren’t up to it.

That’s about right, to my mind. What’s been said at length about this project, from municipal officials, from the vendors hired, and in my research and travels to other cities (more on that later in the series) supports Sue’s comment.

That’s what makes a series, book, and video documentary about this project valuable: it’s not just about Whitewater (much as I love the town), but about Whitewater when compared with other places. One should have the goal of encouraging a place one loves to adopt the sound practices of others; yet in the end, people choose freely, sometimes well, sometimes poorly.

Writing is sometimes commentary, but more often chronicle.


Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
8 years ago

Yes that’s the size of it. So much for a Common Council that actually thinks, but that’s your point, right? Kidd was all for it, city officials just talked out of their hats, and Donohue will have long since cashed the check by the time it’s really stinking around these parts. We really are paying for basement level work.

8 years ago

Thanks for highlighting my comment, John. 🙂

8 years ago

It’s striking how the first 50 posts seem like a conversation between people speaking two languages, yours and a collection of city politicians/manager/superintendent speaking another language. A series/website/video is a bet on which language more closely reflects reality. It’s universalism vs. particularism. Describing a “lingua franca” for whitewater (thursday) is a funny way of saying they’re the ones with the language deficiency.