Over at Reason’s Hit & Run, Matt Welch responds to the big-government loving author of In Defense of Government, Jacob Weisberg of Slate. Weisberg, in a Slate post entitled, “How the Financial Collapse Killed Libertarianism” contends that
The best thing you can say about libertarians is that because their views derive from abstract theory, they tend to be highly principled and rigorous in their logic. Those outside of government at places like the Cato Institute and Reason magazine are just as consistent in their opposition to government bailouts as to the kind of regulation that might have prevented one from being necessary. “Let failed banks fail” is the purist line. This approach would deliver a wonderful lesson in personal responsibility, creating thousands of new jobs in the soup-kitchen and food-pantry industries.
Welch responds, in a post entitled, “The Eternal Death of Libertarianism“:
There is no space in Weisberg’s conception of “libertarians” for people like, for instance, me: Not remotely a utopian, not “of the right,” never read an Ayn Rand novel, spent high school playing sports instead of reading political philosophy, don’t want to do history over (except for Game 5 of the 1986 ALCS), and don’t pine for some presumably awful world where everyone shares my political views. (And, I might add, unlike Weisberg, I don’t want to convert my political views into increased state power over fellow citizens who don’t happen to agree with me.)
No, I just think that, all things being equal, capitalism is vastly superior to socialism, government is by definition inefficient, and would be much better off focused on essential tasks, rather than, say, nationalizing hundred-billion-dollar chunks of the mortgage industry, or trying to guarantee that asset prices never depreciate. In my world, at least, not all regulation is automatically evil, just ripe for being gamed by the very interests being regulated, and so better when pruned back.
Notes:
(1) Game 5 of the ALCS — Boston over California in eleven innings
(2) Weisberg’s book on big government is apparently out of print, but available through used booksellers on Amazon starting at $.01.