FREE WHITEWATER

Author Archive for JOHN ADAMS

Daily Bread for 10.8.23: In Eau Claire, Miniature Horse Becomes Neighborhood Celebrity

 Good morning.

Sunday in Whitewater will be mostly cloudy with a high of 54. Sunrise is 7:00 and sunset 6:23 PM for 11h 22m 45s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 31.4% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1871, Peshtigo, Wisconsin was devastated by a fire that took 1,200 lives. The fire caused over $2 million in damages and destroyed 1.25 million acres of forest. This was the greatest human loss due to fire in the history of the United States. The Peshtigo Fire was overshadowed by the Great Chicago Fire which occurred on the same day, killing 250 people and lasting three days. While the Chicago fire is said to have been started by a cow kicking over a lantern, it is uncertain how the Peshtigo fire began.


In Eau Claire, a miniature horse becomes a neighborhood celebrity:


What’s the Connection Between Seahorses and Salt?:

Daily Bread for 10.7.23: Wisconsin Manufacturers Less Pessimistic About the Economy

 Good morning.

Saturday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of 55. Sunrise is 6:59 and sunset 6:25 PM for 11h 25m 36s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 40.6% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1780, American militia defeat royalist irregulars led by British major Patrick Ferguson at the Battle of Kings Mountain in South Carolina, often regarded as the turning point in the war’s Southern theater.


There are times when “less pessimistic” is enough. Joe Schulz reports Wisconsin manufacturers less pessimistic about the economy this year, but still face stresses (‘Workforce tops list of concerns from manufacturers, as inflation and supply chain worries lessen’):

Wisconsin manufacturers are less pessimistic about the economy than last year and remain optimistic about their companies, but workforce challenges continue to be a top concern even as inflation and supply chain worries lessen.

That’s according to a new report from the Wisconsin Center for Manufacturing & Productivity, a public-private partnership that connects companies with resources. It surveyed 415 manufacturing executives from across the state and also took input from focus groups in Madison, Milwaukee, Green Bay and Menomonie.

Manufacturing stakeholders on Wednesday discussed the results at Titletown Tech in Green Bay. The survey found that 51 percent of manufacturers believe the business climate is headed in the right direction, but it’s not quite back to levels seen in 2021. That year, 55 percent said it was going in the right direction.

The survey shows that manufacturers are split regarding opinions on the health of Wisconsin’s economy. Twenty-three percent believe the state economy is growing; 36 percent say it’s mostly flat; 26 percent think it’s slowing down; and 12 percent believe it’s in a recession.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, America’s gross domestic product grew in the first two quarters of 2023 with annualized growth around 2 percent each quarter. After some forecasters predicted recessions in 2022 and 2023, forecasters at UCLA are predicting 2024 will be a weak year for economic growth, before rebounding in 2025.


Wisconsin Life | Bird Man:

Daily Bread for 10.6.23: National Economy Adds 336,000 Jobs in September

 Good morning.

Friday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of 55. Sunrise is 6:58 and sunset 6:26 PM for 11h 28m 28s of daytime. The moon is in its third quarter with 49.7% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1995, the first planet orbiting another sun, 51 Pegasi b, is discovered.


Talmon Joseph Smith reports The U.S. added 336,000 jobs in September:

In a sign of continued economic stamina, payrolls grew by 336,000 on a seasonally adjusted basis, the Labor Department said on Friday. The increase, almost double economists’ expectations, serves as a confirmation of the labor market’s vitality and the overall hardiness of an economy facing challenges from a variety of forces.

The unemployment rate was 3.8 percent, unchanged from August, as joblessness ticked back near record lows.

September was the 33rd consecutive month of job growth. Hiring figures for July and August were revised upward, with employers adding 119,000 more jobs to the labor market than previously recorded. But wage gains were cooler than expected, with average hourly earnings rising 0.2 percent from the previous month and 4.2 percent from September 2022.

Federal Reserve policymakers have tried to rein in both wages and prices by pulling up interest rates. Some financial analysts believe that continued resilience in wage gains and job growth could hasten a downturn by prompting the Fed to raise borrowing costs further during its next meeting in early November.

The unemployment rate has been below 4 percent since December 2021, a stretch not achieved since the late 1960s.

“This is an economy on fire,” said Samuel Rines, an economist and the managing director of Corbu, a financial research firm.

There’s a local aspect to these national gains: Will Whitewater continue on a new course, and enjoy some of these national gains, or will she fall back into the old stagnation of those long-time politicians, special interests, operatives, and catspaws who have time and again left Whitewater behind the national pace? Whitewater’s residents are as capable as any in America, yet Whitewater historically has not kept pace with it’s share of national successes. 

Residents of Whitewater deserve as much as anyone in America, and would have more than they now have, if the serial failures and excuses over all these many years had not left the city with less. See Whitewater’s Still Waiting for That Boom (about the time in 2020 just before the pandemic).


What’s in the Night Sky October 2023:

Film: Tuesday, October 10th, 1:00 PM @ Seniors in the Park, You Hurt My Feelings

Tuesday, Tuesday, October 10th at 1:00 PM, there will be a showing of You Hurt My Feelings @ Seniors in the Park, in the Starin Community Building:

Comedy/Drama/Romance

Rated R (language)

1 hour, 33 minutes (2023)

A sharply observed comedy about a novelist whose long standing marriage is suddenly upended when she overhears her husband give his honest reaction to her latest book. A film about trust, lies, and the things we say to the people we love most. Stars Julia Louis-Dreyfus and Tobias Menzies.

One can find more information about You Hurt My Feelings at the Internet Movie Database.

Daily Bread for 10.5.23: It’s Fat Bear Week in America

 Good morning.

Thursday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of 73. Sunrise is 6:57 and sunset 6:28 PM for 11h 31m 19s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 60.7% of its visible disk illuminated.

Whitewater’s Landmarks Committee meets at 6 PM

On this day in 1813, The Army of the Northwest defeats a British and Native Canadian force threatening Detroit.


  Whitewater is a place of outstanding natural beauty, with a fair number of wild mammals moving through, although I don’t believe that we’ve yet had a visit from bears. Nearby communities have had bear sightings, but we have not had bears in town. See Black bears in Wisconsin, here’s what you should know (“according to information found on a Facebook page titled: “Walworth County Scanner Updates,” black bears have been spotted, as reported by commenters on the site, near Whitewater and Elkhorn.”)

As it turns out, it’s Fat Bear Week in America. If it’s a celebratory week in America, then it’s also that week in Wisconsin; if Wisconsin, then Whitewater. About the week, Natalie B. Compton reports For Fat Bear Week, a close-up look at lifestyles of the fat and famous:

KATMAI NATIONAL PARK AND PRESERVE, Alaska — You won’t be able to hear a bear walking behind you here. Despite weighingaround1,000 pounds, the park’s 2,200 brown bears are inordinately quiet. But you will register their roars from deep in the woods. And the snapping of salmon spines when an apex predator cracks open a cold one.

Those sounds are particularly loud in a “bear vortex,” which is how wildlife guide and photographer Jon Kuiper describes being surrounded by four bears. A “bear-nado” means you’re at the center of six bears. Eight bears is a “bear-nami,” and “double digits is just like, ‘bear-icane,’” said Kuiper, 35, who’s earned the nickname “Bear Daddy.” He has a large tattoo of his favorite bear, 32 “Chunk,” on his right triceps.

Kuiper works at Brooks Lodge at Brooks Camp, arguably the best place in the world to see swarms of bears up close.

We may not see any bears, fat or skinny, in Whitewater this week; we may see some in the years ahead. 

(NB: a normal community is a place of many people and many activities. It’s possible, and now necessary more than ever, to balance admiration for the natural, the privately charitable, and the politically worthy while also committing to a long campaign against the politically unworthy. A well-individuated person submits the latter to a relentless critique so that it does not stain those former wonders and pursuits. Best of all, almost a blessing one might say: those better wonders and pursuits will sustain normal people in an attritional campaign against the politically unworthy.) 


France races to stamp out bedbugs before Olympics:

Daily Bread for 10.4.23: The Shape of Decline to Come (and How to Carry On)

 Good morning.

Wednesday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of 76. Sunrise is 6:56 and sunset 6:30 PM for 11h 34m 11s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 70.6% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1795, Napoleon first rises to prominence by suppressing counter-revolutionary rioters threatening the National Convention.


 There are those wondering, today, what last night’s meeting of the Whitewater Common Council means for the city. A few offerings:

  1. It was inevitable, or nearly so, that the Whitewater Common Council would hire a third attorney, at municipal expense, to counsel them in their ill-advised posture toward Whitewater’s current city manager. One is reminded of a passage from Proverbs: ‘Like a dog going back to his vomit, a fool repeats his folly.’ Over these last weeks since August, I’ve contended in correspondence or conversation with residents that this council would most certainly hire a third attorney. 

  2. A key point about this council majority: bad often goes to worse, and that’s because bad seldom recognizes itself. It’s something like the contention that the first condition of a barbarian is that he doesn’t know he’s a barbarian. That’s this majority: about as dense and dim a group as this city has or could produce. It’s as though someone called central casting and asked for a mix of deep ignorance and unmerited arrogance. Credit where credit is due: if someone did ask for those types, then central casting sure delivered for Whitewater!

  3. There’s no point in expecting good judgment from this crew; that was never going to happen. Nothing but nothing a serious person could say or write would ever matter to these ridiculous people. One speaks and writes for others; neither in public affairs nor at table would anyone profitably converse with the members of this majority. 

  4. Since April, this council majority has become an impediment to its own city. 

  5. No normal professional would stay working for a city where the council majority is a collection of mediocrities and misfits. Of course normal people will head for the door — expect much more of this. 

  6. For some of these council members, the exodus of others is like an unconfessed goal, so that there is no one better to make them look inevitably worse by comparison. Some people prefer to rule in dirt rather than serve in cleanliness. 

  7. No one who sees a few clips of this council majority would want to work for this city. As long as this council majority persists, Whitewater (including the already execrable CDA) will never be able to hire good employees. Losers, liars, layabouts, and liquor pigs are all we will be able to attract.  The former council majority put together good hires and a good team; it’s all downhill for hiring since April. 

  8. You broke it, you bought it. The city should look elsewhere for success and prosperity, but it’s a sad truth that the portion of a libertarian’s time focused on the Whitewater Common Council will yield fruitful examples of their inadequacies. There’s something to be said for the role of happy warrior.  Never a dull moment. 

The first step is to recognize that this council majority has nothing good to offer Whitewater; the next step is to turn toward those others in the city who offer in their private efforts incomparably more. 

There is a way out for the community, itself, however, as this libertarian blogger has written repeatedly: turn away from this inadequate and addled band on council, and work to build a better city apart from them. They represent the bottom of Whitewater; look elsewhere for the top. There is no better community in which to be, embarrassment and inadequacy of this common council notwithstanding. I’ve written this way for years; it’s never been more true than now.

On that better private course, see Waiting for Whitewater’s Dorothy Day, Something Transcendent, and in the MeantimeAn Oasis Strategy, The Community Space, People Bring Color. and From Government, Failure is Both Loss and Distraction


Is This the Best Salt In the World?:

Daily Bread for 10.3.23: What Direct and Clear Looks Like

 Good morning.

Tuesday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of 82. Sunrise is 6:55 and sunset 6:32 PM for 11h 37m 03s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 78.8% of its visible disk illuminated.

The Whitewater Common Council meets tonight beginning at 6:30 PM:

On this day in 1952, the United Kingdom successfully tests a nuclear weapon in the Montebello Islands, Western Australia, to become the world’s third nuclear power.


Consider the following account, from Matt Levine’s Money Stuff column, of the allegations against crypto king Sam Bankman-Fried:

The essential charges against Sam Bankman-Fried are:

  • Customers deposited billions of dollars at his crypto exchange, FTX, to buy crypto.
  • Bankman-Fried’s trading firm, Alameda Research, secretly took that money to gamble on crypto tokens and make weird illiquid venture investments.
  • Also a lot of the money seems to have been siphoned off to make political donations, buy celebrity endorsements, pay for Bahamas real estate for Bankman-Fried and his family, etc.
  • When customers started asking for their money back last November, it wasn’t there.

This is bad! The basic combination of “the customers’ money is gone” and “you lived in a $30 million penthouse” is really killer. That’s the most basic outline of a financial fraud: The customers don’t have the money anymore, and you do.

But Bankman-Fried is going to trial tomorrow [10.3], and here’s Michael Lewis on 60 Minutes being asked “do you think he knowingly stole customers’ money” and answering “put that way, no.” So I suppose there will be a defense.

What is the defense? I think the defense is roughly: “The crypto market crashed, there was a run on the bank, and the run on the bank is what evaporated the customers’ money. It was an accident, perhaps a careless accident, but not theft.”[1] This is a very hard defense to pull off!

The first thing that is hard about it is that it is not at all intuitive that a “run on the bank” should be possible at a crypto exchange like FTX. The intuitive way for a crypto exchange to work is:

  1. I deposit $100.

  2. I buy $100 of Bitcoin on the exchange.

  3. The exchange has $100 of Bitcoin earmarked for me.

  4. When I go to withdraw my $100 of Bitcoin, if it’s not there, that means someone stole it.

Levine goes on in greater detail, but he ably presents the allegations involving a crypto exchange and a trading firm (often abstruse subjects) succinctly and clearly. 

In doing so, he does credit to himself and shows respect to his readers. 

It should not be hard for small-town politicians in Whitewater, Wisconsin to speak as succinctly and clearly to residents about local topics. 


Video captures fireball lighting up Oxford sky:

Daily Bread for 10.2.23: City Staff Members Speak on Behalf of City Manager

 Good morning.

Monday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of 82. Sunrise is 6:53 and sunset 6:33 PM for 11h 39m 56s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 87.7% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1780, John André, a British Army officer, is hanged as a spy by the Continental Army.  


  Embedded above is a part (@ 2:22:00) of the 9.19.23 Whitewater Common Council meeting. The video begins with remarks from five leading city hall employees about Whitewater’s city manager. These employees can speak for themselves, as they do in a story from Whitewaterwise (the only professional journalism in Whitewater) entitled, City staff members speak in support of Weidl; council members continue to consider management goals.

From that reporting, one reads that 

On Tuesday [9.19.23], staff members who came forward in support of Weidl’s management style included Whitewater Police Chief Dan Meyer, Whitewater Fire and EMS Chief Kelly Freeman, Whitewater Human Resources Director Sara Marquardt, Whitewater City Clerk Karri Anderberg, and Whitewater Administrative Assistant for Economic Development Bonnie Miller.

Addressing members of the city council, Meyer said: “I’d just like to give my support for John’s management plan and explain a little bit about the respect that I have for his management style in general.” 

Addressing Gerber, he said: “To your point, Jill, the way his management is going, from my perspective, John’s been a breath of fresh air in terms of providing direct and actionable information for me. When I call or text John with confidential updates that we’re working on, he responds immediately — I’m not talking like five minutes, I’m talking like now. When I need an answer for a personnel or budget issue, I get a response immediately, which, in turn, allows me to do my job.”

Offering an example of his working relationship with Weidl, and citing demographic changes within the community as among challenges facing the police department, Meyer said: “The first day I met John, I explained to him how this has impacted us with the communication challenges, cultural differences, lack of trust in government, non-familial living situations.”

Meyer said Weidl was “engaged,” describing him as a manager who “showed up to dig into this complicated issue,”  adding that Weidl asked him to complete a Request for Quote (RFQ) for an immigration attorney to help create a bilingual immigration guide.

“So that stretched my comfort level with something I had no experience doing; it made me grow,” Meyer said.

He added: “Ultimately, I’m not always going to like the answers that I get from John, but (I) understand that (it’s) not always about getting what you want. At the end of the day, I’ve got a ton of respect for his approach to the job, and I think the city is better off with him here.” 

Freeman cited the history and the referendum which led to the formation and funding of the city’s fire department.

“I just wanted to echo what Chief Meyer had to say in regards to working with the city manager,” Freeman said.

Citing a desire to create perspective, he told council members that in 2014 or 2015, the city had a fire department and rescue squad which was housed in the same place, but, he said, it did not “operate in unison.”

…..

Addressing the council, Anderberg described herself as a “new employee” of only four months.

“My journey here marks a stark departure from a previous experience in another municipality where the highest official’s demeanor was far from what we expect in public service. In that environment, accusing, yelling, and public spectacles were at an alarming high and very common. It was a very toxic situation and unhealthy work environment,” she said.

She added that in the time that she has been employed in Whitewater, the city has undergone, by her assessment a “remarkable transformation.

“Our dedicated staff are receiving training and support like never before. We’re embracing new technologies that promise to propel our city into a brighter future. Departments that once were plagued by ineffective leadership have been experiencing a complete turnaround in just the four months I’ve been here.”

Anderberg said her department was undergoing a modernization, during which staff members were uploading all of the city’s forms to its website, giving residents online access. Additionally, she said, a new agenda management system was synchronizing agendas “across our committees and common council.”

….

At the podium, Miller said that she has been working with the city’s CDA (Community Development Authority) since 2018, when she began administrative duties in a part-time capacity.

At the time, she said, “I was not new to economic development; I worked as a legal assistant for 22 years for attorney Mitch Simon, who served as legal counsel for the CDA.”

At city hall, she continued, “I have experienced several changes in leadership over the five years I’ve been here, having reported to two CDA directors, who were both here for a short time. During the many months without a CDA director, I reported to city manager Cameron Clapper. If I had to characterize those first five years on the whole, I would say, for me, they were without definitive direction and lacked effective leadership.”

After Clapper left to pursue another job, she said, she reported to an interim CDA director and then Weidl, first in his interim capacity and then as city manager.

Of Weidl, she said, “It was like someone finally started the engine and stepped on the gas. In my experience, John brings an energy to the city hall that spills over to everyone in the building. He set a high standard, and expects us all to be making the best use of our workday. He is direct, but respectful, sets goals and objectives, and has created an environment where I personally feel safe to spread my wings and accept new challenges.”

Miller said that under Weidl’s management, she finds she has the necessary tools to perform her work, and, she said, she is afforded opportunities to learn and grow.

….

Sara Marquardt said she was in agreement with Miller’s assessment of the city manager. 

“So I will not reiterate her feelings, but I do want to ask of this council, when we are discussing goals, when we are discussing the issues that are affecting us — no, it has not always been easy — but in order to move this city forward, we need to be free to concentrate on its objectives, cheer the positives, and stop the behaviors that continue to impede our progress.”

A key point:

All of these people, including and especially the members of the Whitewater Common Council, are members of the government. Scrutiny does not begin from seven council members toward city staff.  No, and no again.

Scrutiny should — and must — begin from any of 14,889 residents toward the Whitewater Common Council, itself.  The words and actions of these several people are the first points of assessment of reasonableness, competency, and professionalism in local government. 


 

Daily Bread for 10.1.23: The Shamelessness of the Special-Interest Men

 Good morning.

Sunday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of 84. Sunrise is 6:52AM and sunset 6:35 PM for 11h 42m 48s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 93.3% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 331 BC, Alexander the Great defeats Darius III of Persia in the Battle of Gaugamela.


  In a small town like Whitewater, where the Whitewater Common Council and the Community Development Authority are beset or controlled by special interests (under the thumb of principals & operatives, and behaving as catspaws), it’s worth considering the shamelessness of the special-interest men who afflict this city. 

To be shameless — without embarrassment in self-promotion, self-dealing, lying, or ignorance — works to the advantage of these men.  

Here’s why. 

First, when they demand something selfish, something that’s an apparent conflict of interest, the very audacity of their demands stuns normal & well-adjusted people. It’s that stunned moment that is to the benefit of the special-interest men: in the surprise and hesitation of ordinary people, the avaricious, gluttonous, and proud move forward. They seize advantage of others’ moments of reflection to take and take again.

Second, these types know that if an audacious demand stuns at first instance, the repetition of that demand works a greater power when forced over and over. To insist once surprises normal people, but to insist over and over works a second power by wearing away resistance.

Special-interest men will keep demanding, and their catspaws, dupes, suckers, and stooges will keep demanding on their behalf. A bloated & bloviating dupe, who can’t make a coherent argument at any given moment, can at least make the same incoherent argument repeatedly and hope to wear others down. 

This is notably useful for special-interest leaders of Whitewater: they don’t need knowledgeable mouthpieces on the Whitewater Common Council or Community Development Association, as even a low-quality operative or stooge can repeat the same underhanded and poorly-expressed demands again, again, and again. 

Perhaps this shouldn’t surprise: The kind of men or women willing to be toadies for others aren’t likely to have any worthy talents of their own. If they had worthy talents of their own, needless to say, then they wouldn’t be toadies in the first place. 

Of toadies, here’s one etymology of that word: 

In 17th-century Europe, a toadeater was a showman’s assistant whose job was to make the boss look good. The toadeater would eat (or pretend to eat) what were supposed to be poisonous toads. The charlatan in charge would then “save” the toad-afflicted assistant by expelling the poison. It’s little wonder that such assistants became symbolic of extreme subservience, and that toadeater became a word for any obsequious underling. By the early 1800s, it had been shortened and altered to toady, our current term for a servile self-seeker. By the mid-1800s, toady was also being used as a verb meaning “to engage in sycophancy.”


Daily Bread for 9.30.23: Fierce or Bust

 Good morning.

Saturday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of 82. Sunrise is 6:51AM and sunset 6:31 PM for 11h 45m 41s of daytime. The moon is a waning gibbous with 98.2% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1954, the U.S. Navy submarine USS Nautilus is commissioned as the world’s first nuclear-powered vessel.


In a small town like Whitewater, where the Whitewater Common Council and the Community Development Authority are beset or controlled by special interests (under the thumb of principals & operatives, and behaving as catspaws), residents need good & honest reporting on local developments.

While FREE WHITEWATER is a website of commentary and not journalism, this libertarian blogger can tell the difference between solid journalism (of which this city has had almost none until Whitewaterwise) and failed and fraudulent efforts (of which this city has had many). 

Seth Stern writes In defense of aggressive small-town newspapers:

The prevalence of “news deserts” has apparently led some to think it’s normal for neighborhood news outlets to function as lapdogs rather than watchdogs. A Marion [in Kansas] grocery store owner told the Times that the local paper “should of course be positive about everything that is going on in Marion, and not stir things up and look at the negative side of things.” 

Fluff pieces may be good for business (at least in the short term), but we wouldn’t need a First Amendment if the press’s role were to applaud the status quo. 

The ordeal [conflict in Marion] also belies the notion that small towns don’t need journalism because “everyone knows each other” and holds their friends accountable. Marion County has almost twelve thousand people. Small-town politicians and elites may all know each other, but there are still plenty of people outside the bubble. The press’s job is to bring them in. And even towns far smaller than Marion—where everyone actually might know each other—are by no means always exemplars of good government. 

The truth is that the powerful complain about aggressive media coverage everywhere, not just in small towns. Find me a government of any size that doesn’t think the press is too hard on it. The difference is that small-town officials often have far greater ability to meaningfully retaliate against negative coverage rather than just complaining about it. That can mean filing frivolous SLAPP suits or pulling contracts for legal notices

These efforts are especially likely to succeed in small towns because the more desperate news outlets become for money, the more susceptible they become to intimidation and self-censorship. 

This last year has seen a furious, persistent effort by a few men on the Whitewater CDA and the Whitewater Common Council to preserve special interest control over both those public bodies. 

An intensification of scrutiny has never been more necessary for this city. 


More than 70% of Nagorno-Karabakh’s population flees as future uncertain for those who remain:

Daily Bread for 9.29.23: Redeeming Social Media

 Good morning.

Friday in Whitewater will be partly cloudy with a high of 71. Sunrise is 6:50 AM and sunset 6:39 PM for 11h 48m 34s of daytime. The moon is full with 100% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1789, the United States Department of War first establishes a regular army with a strength of several hundred men.


Yair Rosenberg offers suggestions on How to Redeem Social Media (‘The next generation of platforms doesn’t have to make the same mistakes as the previous one’):

The slow collapse of Twitter has inspired a host of would-be successors. Millions of people are trying out new social-media platforms such as Meta’s Threads in a textbook triumph of enthusiasm over experience. I’m sure that creating free content for a social-media platform run by an unaccountable billionaire will turn out differently this time, we tell ourselves, as though we were all born yesterday.

….

Establish rules of the road.

For years, Facebook permitted Holocaust denial—until it didn’t. For months, Twitter throttled an array of claims about COVID-19—some false, some merely controversial—until it didn’t. Both platforms banned Donald Trump, then reversed course. Meanwhile, Chinese officials who insinuate that COVID-19 began in the United States and work to obfuscate their regime’s horrific repression of Uyghur Muslims mostly go unpunished. The problem is not that social-media companies such as Twitter or Facebook moderate their content. It’s that their process is opaque and seemingly capricious, and the precise basis for decisions is rarely disclosed to the public. Rather than cultivate a healthy online community, this sort of arbitrary administration breeds distrust.

What’s needed instead is a transparent set of detailed criteria governing suspensions, bans, and other punishments that is clearly explained, regularly updated, and consistently applied. Social-media platforms have typically kept the specifics of these determinations private, because they want to avoid opening themselves up to controversy. But making moderation a black box has invited a different form of controversy. Because users could never tell exactly why certain content was taken down or suppressed, the platforms became easy targets for suspicion, paranoia, and accusations of bias. It’s true that no set of public-moderation principles will satisfy all comers. But that’s a feature, not a bug. Users will be able to choose where to spend their time based on whether a platform aligns with their ideals, and platforms will no longer be plagued by users who are constantly aggrieved by their treatment.

(Emphasis added.)

Clarity of rule-making and enforcement benefits platforms and users. 


Man Skydives Straight Onto an Inflatable Unicorn: