Good morning.
Wednesday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of 64. Sunrise is 7:12 and sunset 6:07 PM for 10h 54m 35s of daytime. The moon is a waxing crescent with 13.9% of its visible disk illuminated.
There will be a meet and greet with Whitewater’s new parks director, Kevin Boehm, at 5:30 PM.
On this day in 1945, the USSR‘s nuclear program receives plans for the United States plutonium bomb from Klaus Fuchs at the Los Alamos National Laboratory.
I’ve written before about Whitewater’s probable near-future. See The Shape of Decline to Come (and How to Carry On). This morning, a few more thoughts about the near-future, a time that will stretch between ten and fifteen years. (The estimate of this period’s length is a cautious one based on how long Whitewater has been stagnant; it may last longer.)
A reminder: Whitewater deserves better from its common council majority; this city is better than its council majority. Whitewater deserves better from its community development authority’s majority; this city is better than that authority’s majority.
What is this conflict about? For a year, Whitewater’s special interests, using their operatives and stooges, have embarked on a campaign to ensure that they continue to control economic development in Whitewater. They view a public institution like the Whitewater Community Development Authority as their private property and will not accept the direction of the current city administration to establish professional, public development as other communities do. A few landlords and bankers in Whitewater will not accept a city that is not under their thumb. That’s what this conflict is about. All the rest is pretext and lies.
What comes next? These special interests (a few landlords and bankers) will use the council majority to fire or force out this city manager, after which they will hand-pick a new city manager and an economic development director who will take direction only from them.
Gradually and then Suddenly. Hemingway’s observation about calamity from The Sun Also Rises is oft-quoted for its insight into decline:
“How did you go bankrupt?” Bill asked.
“Two ways,” Mike said. “Gradually and then suddenly.”
Whitewater has seen the gradual through many years of stagnation. She will now see the sudden, in which over two or three years there will be a steep decline, leaving the city in an inferior position for many years thereafter. In that two to three-year period, public employees and small private businesses will head for the door, if they can. For public employees in the city, but also school district and university, it will prove true that “Whitewater (including the already execrable CDA) will never be able to hire good employees. Losers, liars, layabouts, and liquor pigs are all we will be able to attract.”
Whitewater will become the undoubted sick person of the area, and other towns will capitalize on Whitewater’s coming infirmity to attract those who can relocate elsewhere. Obvious point: While I respect the right and need of people & businesses to leave for their own well-being, there is no circumstance whatever in which I would leave Whitewater. Whitewater is for me, as I have mentioned, the work of a lifetime. One’s own perspective cannot, however, obscure this local truth: the cronyism and self-dealing of a few local men will leave thousands of residents worse off.
The Limits of Speech. Free speech only influences those who care to listen. By definition, special interests care for themselves at the expense of the common good. For these types, Whitewater is not a city of 14,889, but rather about two dozen or so. This libertarian blogger has never written to persuade Whitewater’s special interests. Of course not: If they cared about others, they wouldn’t have kept the town stagnant nor would they be acting to overturn its city administration. They don’t care; they speak only enough platitudes to deceive. They are liars by habit if not by nature. They accuse others of the very transgressions that they commit each day. One writes not for them but to affirm what one believes to be true even in surrounding conditions of dishonesty and corruption.
Mutual Aid. Mutual aid is a term often applied between emergency services and police departments to support each other in a crisis. Whitewater will need to encourage private residents who can provide mutual aid to each other in coming times of empty small stores, increased poverty, addiction, crime, and social disorder. It’s not enough to provide financial assistance (although that matters); residents will have to bolster programs that encourage residents to support each other as they overcome social disadvantages and disorders. Top-down, paternalistic approaches will not be enough in this approaching time of sudden decline.
There’s an irony that one who by nature and nurture is distant and detached writes about the need for mutual association. There are, it seems, occasional ironies to be found in unfolding community tragedies. Each person plays a role in a larger community. Sometimes a person can prescribe the right medication without being able to manufacture that medicine himself.
And so, and so: “There is a way out for the community, itself, however, as this libertarian blogger has written repeatedly: turn away from this inadequate and addled band on council, and work to build a better city apart from them. They represent the bottom of Whitewater; look elsewhere for the top. There is no better community in which to be, embarrassment and inadequacy of this common council notwithstanding. I’ve written this way for years; it’s never been more true than now.”
See Waiting for Whitewater’s Dorothy Day, Something Transcendent, and in the Meantime, An Oasis Strategy, The Community Space, People Bring Color. From Government, Failure is Both Loss and Distraction, and The Shape of Decline to Come (and How to Carry On).
Extremely bleak but honest. Guess this seems about right. How soon until you think they force the city manager out?
Sometimes candor demands a bleak assessment.
They will act as quickly as possible. They almost certainly have an ambitious timetable for 2023 and early 2024. Their goals will be to remove the city manager this year, and then promptly begin a replacement process for both the city manager and to complete the hiring for the now-vacant CDA director position. They’ll need catspaws in those roles to ensure that they can direct various public funds to their preferred, crony recipients.
These goals will need to be accomplished before the next spring general election in April. (If the election in April goes bad for incumbents who’ve backed overturning the city administration, the special interests will still have accomplished their main aim of installing new appointees to control development policy and money.)
Afterward, they will use the new hires they pick to force out any employees in city hall who, in their estimation, stood against their plans. (In the meantime, they will tell these employees that their concerns are only about the city manager, and no one else will be affected.) They lie when they speak, so these assurances should mean nothing to a sensible person.
Having begun this process, they will not stop. Partway in does not suit their plans. They will continue regardless of community sentiment. If they cared about community sentiment, then they wouldn’t be special interests in the first place.
so you don’t think that public comment will matter?
I think public comment matters to almost everyone. When people speak at a microphone, for example, it matters to most people. It matters much less, however, to Whitewater’s special interests when they have a financial interest at stake. They’ll take as much as they want and worry about the recuperations later.
In general, they have a low opinion of contrary voices. They’re entiled, and feel that they’re deserving of more. It’s a small town, and for anyone to think himself better is deluded, but these interests have deluded themselves and others for years. They’ll not stop now. Best guess: they assume that residents will roll over for them. Upset for a day or two, and then resigned to the special interest lie that only a few people matter.
They’ll push on.
so if whitewater might maybe go into sudden decline why would thet take the risk?
They don’t see the risk of decline for others but they do perceive a risk to themselves of not controlling development. They’ve survived (personally) the Great Recession and the pandemic so they’re sure that they can manage what comes next. The Great Recession and pandemic, however, together left Whitewater debilitated and stagnant. This last year as shown that Whitewater can manage better without these special interests than it ever did with them.
That’s both an economic threat to their selfish interests and their reputations. Their priority is to regain control of development policy for themselves and then to erase or disparage any memory of progress in Whitewater over the last year.
They’ll work as quickly as they can — they’ve lined up what they need — to achieve as much as possible as soon as possible.
And is there any chance to be wrong(change) this incredibly bleak forecasting?
Good afternoon.
I cannot predict the future with certainty; what I offer is an estimate only, based on observations sincere yet imperfect. Yet for it all, there are residents with whom I have corresponded and conversed over the last year who have said these men would not go as far as they have, and at each moment what seemed probable to me has, in fact, come to pass. I claim no extrasensory perception. Instead, these few men and their catspaws have been so obvious that it’s enough to look plainly at their actions and words and estimate the effects thereof.
There’s nothing special about me; there’s something especially rotten about this ilk.
I do think it’s possible to mitigate much of the harm that awaits, and now more than never there are two tasks before someone who cares about this small city.
First, to develop and propose steps to keep Whitewater going in spite of special interest control of the Whitewater Common Council and the Whitewater Community Development Authority. They’ve made plain what they want and what they will do; expecting better of them would be expecting too much of them.
Residents can achieve meaningful results for themselves despite below-average majorites on those two bodies. It will be hard, but it can be done. An ongloing project like this is a moral obligation in a community that will descend quickly into a worse state. (As always, a reminder: I have no personal grievance, but instead only a social and political concern.)
Second, a chronicle of this time, detailed and avaiable to others, will be useful to show residents what they can accomplish when they are free of inadequate schemers. It will also be useful as a warning of what might befall other communities if they allow themsleves to become prey to a few manipulators.
It’s rare that this blogger favors military metaphors for civilian life, but the concept of the happy warrior now comes to mind. (It’s often applied to both Al Smith and Franklin Roosevelt, ironically sometimes allies, sometimes adversaries.) We are only ordinary people, all equal, but we can in our own ways try to carry on as happy warriors.
It is good fortune and blessing, both, it is to find onself in Whitewater. As with marriage, ‘for better or worse, in sickness and in health,’ one lives and loves steadfastly. There is no place that I would rather be, or perhaps, just perhaps, could be.
Each day and every day, one lives the life of a happy warrior, approaching the day’s challenges from the perspective of a dark horse underdog.
In a city of thousands, there are countless ways first to hold, and then to advance.
Sad, yes, of course it is.
Daunting, perhaps.
Impossible, not at all.