Press
Press Ethics
by JOHN ADAMS •
We’re a small town, with limited news coverage. Excellence knows no size; greatness depends on principle, not rationalization or self-praise.
For the media that we have, there should be a respect and adherence to true journalistic standards. The Associated Press has a fine set of principles, their Statement of Ethical Principles, from their Managing Editors. These principles are applicable and useful to journalists of any size.
From those standards are two that are indisputably useful and consistent with American values:
RESPONSIBILITY
The good newspaper is fair, accurate, honest, responsible, independent and decent. Truth is its guiding principle.
It avoids practices that would conflict with the ability to report and present news in a fair, accurate and unbiased manner.
The newspaper should serve as a constructive critic of all segments of society. It should reasonably reflect, in staffing and coverage, its diverse constituencies. It should vigorously expose wrongdoing, duplicity or misuse of power, public or private. Editorially, it should advocate needed reform and innovation in the public interest. News sources should be disclosed unless there is a clear reason not to do so. When it is necessary to protect the confidentiality of a source, the reason should be explained.
The newspaper should uphold the right of free speech and freedom of the press and should respect the individual’s right to privacy. The newspaper should fight vigorously for public access to news of government through open meetings and records.
INDEPENDENCE
The newspaper and its staff should be free of obligations to news sources and newsmakers. Even the appearance of obligation or conflict of interest should be avoided.
Newspapers should accept nothing of value from news sources or others outside the profession. Gifts and free or reduced-rate travel, entertainment, products and lodging should not be accepted.
Expenses in connection with news reporting should be paid by the newspaper. Special favors and
special treatment for members of the press should be avoided.Journalists are encouraged to be involved in their communities, to the extent that such activities do not create conflicts of interest.
Involvement in politics, demonstrations and social causes that would cause a conflict of interest, or the appearance of such conflict, should be avoided.
Work by staff members for the people or institutions they cover also should be avoided.
Financial investments by staff members or other outside business interests that could create the impression of a conflict of interest should be avoided.
Stories should not be written or edited primarily for the purpose of winning awards and prizes. Self-serving journalism contests and awards that reflect unfavorably on the newspaper or the profession should be avoided.
The AP also has a Statement of News Values and Principles. In this political season — or any season — their statement on political activities is a worthy standard.
POLITICAL ACTIVITIES:
Editorial employees are expected to be scrupulous in avoiding any political activity, whether they cover politics regularly or not. They may not run for political office or accept political appointment; nor may they perform public relations work for politicians or their groups. Under no circumstances should they donate money to political organizations or political campaigns. They should use great discretion in joining or making contributions to other organizations that may take political stands.
Non-editorial employees must refrain from political activity unless they obtain approval from a manager.
When in doubt, staffers are encouraged to discuss any such concerns with their supervisors. And a supervisor must be informed when a spouse — or other members of an employee’s household — has any ongoing involvement in political causes, either professionally or personally.
Orange Salamander, Twitter
The Orange Salamander for Last Week
by JOHN ADAMS •
2 Millhaven clues: salamander & note, marginalia in library book. Plan, plot, mystery.
If a plan, then a planner. Phil the city consultant? Crush on Felicia the MBA. Time for a visit.
Phil’s office: shambles, papers everywhere, wrapper from yesterday’s egg salad on rye, half-eaten pickle, gum, few scattered trading cards
Phil’s books: dictionary, directory, Time, Newsweek, Government’s Your Co-Pilot, Zoning for Social Control, Pride in Planning, Farmers’ Almanac
Could Phil the planner have left the salamander with Felicia? I scan his office – no hint of nature-loving in him.
Will you be at the community meeting? Phil asks Yes, I reply Felicia will coordinate it, I observe Phil looks up, about to speak
Small-talk with Phil. Nothing unusual about him, unless one correctly concludes that planning others’ lives is unusual
He’s downcast, and volunteers that Felicia hasn’t returned his voicemail from last week
No one ever hears from Phil, he has a poor feel for the community, and the one person he calls doesn’t know he’s alive
I wonder: What is it with all the screwball weirdos in this town sending each other salamanders and ill-timed birthday cards?
In other places, people see ghosts, or werewolves, or Bigfoot Not a single extraterrestrial – it’s 100% terrestrial weirdness in Millhaven
Outside, I see the Millhaven police chief’s latest energy-saver: a three-wheeled cart powered by a human cyclist, like an old ice cream cart
Police carts debuted last month Uniformed officers, horn, lights & message banner: Community policing – We’re green to save you green
City, Police
Where’s Whitewater’s M56 Scorpion Anti-Tank Weapon?
by JOHN ADAMS •
I see at the Wisconsin State Journal that there’s an AP story entitled, For Sale: Army Tank Destroyer. As it turns out, a retired sheriff in Sturgeon Bay has one for sale, at only $7,500.
It’s a fixer-upper, but take a look at how impressive a Scorpion looks, from a museum photo of one:
In May, the Whitewater Register the noted that our police leadership sees three challenges from diversity in our community (“A Diverse Community Presents Challenges”): (1) Hispanics, (2) students, and (3) juveniles. It’s an odd list, of course.
These groups do have one thing in common, though: Not one of them is a match for an M56 Scorpion! No how, no way.
Lights, decals? Why think small? The M56 is the way Whitewater should go. The seller points out features that would also be perfect for leadership ride alongs — the “Craigslist ad offers an idea to a potential buyer: “Pop in a Chevy small block (engine) to the GM Allison transmission and have the BADDEST ride in town!” ”
The Scorpion’s up in Sturgeon Bay, waiting for a serious buyer. There is one man (and probably only one man) in Whitewater who could be that serious buyer. Don’t miss this opportunity; chances like this are rare.
Allow me assist our leadership — here are helpful directions for bring the Scorpion Back from Sturgeon Bay:
1. Head west on WI-42/WI-57 toward S Oxford Ave Continue to follow WI-57
2. Slight left to stay on WI-57
3. Merge onto I-43 S via the ramp to Milwaukee
4. Take exit 4 on the left to merge onto I-43 S/US-45 S toward Beloit Continue to follow I-43 S
5. Take exit 38 for State Hwy 20 toward E Troy
6. Turn right at County Rd L/State Rd 20/WI-20 (signs for E Troy) Continue to follow WI-20
7. Turn left at State Rd 20/WI-20
8. Slight right at US-12
9. Turn right at County Rd P/US-12 Continue to follow US-12
10. Turn left at E Main St/US-12/WI-59
11. Slight left at W Whitewater St/WI-59 Destination will be on the right:
312 W Whitewater St, Whitewater, WI 53190
12. You and your new M56 Scorpion are home!
Economy, Free Markets, Libertarians
Saving Social Security: Policy Warrior
by JOHN ADAMS •
Here’s the third part of a five-part series from Reason.tv entitled, Saving Social Security. The animated video comes from Lineplot, a company that creatively describes financial topics. I posted the first of the series, Pimp My Walker, on October 4th, and the second part, Boom Baby Boom! on October 11th.
Orange Salamander, Twitter
Orange Salamander for 10/17/08
by JOHN ADAMS •
Could Phil the planner have left the salamander with Felicia? I scan his office – no hint of nature-loving in him.
Will you be at the community meeting? Phil asks Yes, I reply Felicia will coordinate it, I observe Phil looks up, about to speak
Small-talk with Phil. Nothing unusual about him, unless one correctly concludes that planning others’ lives is unusual
He’s downcast, and volunteers that Felicia hasn’t returned his voicemail from last week
No one ever hears from Phil, he has a poor feel for the community, and the one person he calls doesn’t know he’s alive
I wonder: What is it with all the screwball weirdos in this town sending each other salamanders and ill-timed birthday cards?
In other places, people see ghosts, or werewolves, or Bigfoot Not a single extraterrestrial – it’s 100% terrestrial weirdness in Millhaven
Outside, I see the Millhaven police chief’s latest energy-saver: a three-wheeled cart powered by a human cyclist, like an old ice cream cart
Police carts debuted last month Uniformed officers, horn, lights & message banner: Community policing – We’re green to save you green
Orange Salamander, Twitter
Orange Salamander for 10/15/08
by JOHN ADAMS •
2 Millhaven clues: salamander & note, marginalia in library book. Plan, plot, mystery.
If a plan, then a planner. Phil the city consultant? Crush on Felicia the MBA. Time for a visit.
Phil’s office: shambles, papers everywhere, wrapper from yesterday’s egg salad on rye, half-eaten pickle, gum, few scattered trading cards
Phil’s books: dictionary, directory, Time, Newsweek, Government’s Your Co-Pilot, Zoning for Social Control, Pride in Planning, Farmers’ Almanac
Libertarians
Bob Barr on CNN’s American Morning
by JOHN ADAMS •
Here’s a video showing Bob Barr’s appearance on CNN’s American Morning.
Barr critiques the other candidates, as though he were a commentator, and not a candidate himself. He’s also blunt the way a Congressional candidate might be, and without the manner of a national candidate.
(I although I hear that Barr thinks well of himself.)
Direct, but never subtle.
Libertarians
Bob Barr Video Ad
by JOHN ADAMS •
Here’s a Bob Barr television ad. I don’t know where this ad might be running, other than on the Internet. Historically, the LP has run almost no media during a campaign.
The ad doesn’t look at all like a presidential campaign ad, or that of a national interest group. It looks more like an ad that a Congressional candidate might run, in a small district where media was inexpensive and political rivals were weak. (Barr, himself, was a member of Congress, and is a former federal prosecutor.)
Barr’s campaign has less than two million dollars raised, and that’s not enough for a national campaign.
Register Watch™
Register Watch™ for the October 16th Issue
by JOHN ADAMS •
The October 16th issue of the Register‘s out, and it’s an autumn issue. What happened? I had to put on reading glasses to make sure that I was looking at the Whitewater Register. The paper has two front page stories on significant fiscal or administrative matters in our school district, and a story on the upcoming Common Council meeting’s agenda.
Well, that’s suitably different – a Whitewater paper with even, straight-forward front page stories about Whitewater.
Other than a discussion of the district’s bus contract, it’s been a while since we’ve had front page coverage of fiscal matters in the district. (The bus contract was hardly a significant matter, compared with academic performance or funding substantive programs.)
The story on the school district’s budget has a simple, clear description of the district’s budget: “Increased tax levy to be on upcoming school board agenda.” The story lists the pertinent facts of district expenditure and revenue, and gives the District Administrator an opportunity to explain her administration’s budget approach. The Administrator describes her method: “We sort of drew a line in the sand with what we estimated we could fund, and if the budget ends up high or low, we adjust the line accordingly.”
Yes.
There’s a below-the-fold story on the District Administrator’s resignation from the WUSD, effective June 30, 2009. I covered that topic earlier this week. June 30th will come, and it will go, too. The real questions we face will not depend on a person, but on good policies, sincerely, faithfully, energetically executed.
There are three photos on the front page, each fall-related, and interesting. Above-the-fold, there’s a nice photo of the Prairie Tillers mural.
Inside, there’s a mixture of local and area news, but how all this will evolve I cannot say. I am seldom surprised.
Whitewater doesn’t lack for smart people, but it does lack people who’ve not grown enervated, offering up the same half-baked excuses for municipal actions, the same clichés. After a while, the mediocre passes for clever. It’s not intellect; it’s a dulling of skills, a decline into complacency. Lack of a straightforward newspaper these last years has made our situation much worse.
Such a paper would benefit the community.
What will emerge I cannot say; it’s enough to know that blogging – a modern version of a longstanding American traditional – is a permanent part of the landscape.
Register Watch™
Register Watch™ for the October 9th Issue
by JOHN ADAMS •
The October 9th issue of the Register is the last issue of the paper without an editor listed on the front page.
(That absence ends with the October 16th issue. On the masthead of the Register, on page 2, there is still a listing for a community editor, nowhere evident to me on the pages of the paper.)
Front Page. The front page features Whitewater’s 2008 homing coming events. It’s a sea of red, with banners, fans, boosters, and two whippets mascots. (Even the whippets are wearing red.)
Below the fold, there’s a story entitled, “Fairest if the Fair Stalker wins ‘Insanity Defense’ .” A Walworth County jury in early October found that defendant, Joseph G. Schraeder was under a mental disease or defect, as defined under Wisconsin law, at the time he encountered Sheri Nelson (a pageant winner).
Under our law, a person may be found to have committed the acts alleged under an offense, but through a mental condition may be found not guilty of those acts. Even though a jury may find the defendant not guilty on this basis, severe mental disorder often lead to placement in a psychiatric facility.
Very few people, in any state that has a legal provision like this, are found not guilty by reason of a mental condition. There are two reasons for this – (1) juries are reluctant to so find, and (2) clear cases involving an established diagnosis are resolved though psychiatric commitment before a criminal trial.
There are always victims in these cases – those who are tormented with letters or visits from someone, speaking incoherently or making odd declarations – have every reason for concern.
As long as the person has been identified correctly, the question is usually whether to commit someone to a psychiatric or criminal institution. Jurors from the community heard the testimony in the case. Juries are often resistant to these defenses, and if they found it applicable in this case, one can presume its application was easily sensible to them.
Whether this resolution might have been reached without trial, one cannot say.
Inside, Ownership. One finds inside a traditional “Statement of Ownership, Managent, and Circulation,” on page 2. The publisher, editor, managing editor, and the headquarters of the Southern Lakes chain’s Whitewater Register all list offices in Burlington.
By contrast, I live in Whitewater, and have only driven through Burlington a few times when I got lost trying to reach another destination. I have no idea what goes on there, although I’ve heard it’s a land of milk and honey, streets paved with gold, where publishers are committed to serious, unbiased, conflict-free journalism without favoritism toward career appointees and incumbent politicians.
Who knows?
Inside, Circulation. Over the last twelve months, the paper reports average total paid and/or requested circulation of 1093 copies per week. In-country paid subscriptions amount to 577, and sales through vendors, etc., amount to 289. We are a city of no less than 14,296 residents.
A number of copies are distributed without charge, although, remarkably, I must not be on the list for one of those copies.
City
Save the Date: Downtown Whitewater, Inc. Birthday Party
by JOHN ADAMS •
Downtown Whitewater, Inc. will be celebrating later this month. More details will follow, but here’s a preliminary post with date and time —
Tuesday October 28, 2008 5:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Cravath Lake Front Building
More information about Downtown Whitewater is available at www.downtownwhitewater.com.
Daily Bread
Daily Bread: October 17, 2008
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning, Whitewater

In Wisconsin history on this date, in 1970, the Wisconsin Historical Society reports that the Richard Nixon visited Green Bay. Nixon went to speak at a dinner honoring Bart Starr.
(Nixon had another Green Bay connection, of sorts. Nixon reportedly considered Vince Lombardi as a possible running mate in 1968, abandoning the idea when he learned that Lombardi was a Democrat. Above, you can see what Lombardi avoided missed.)
There are no public meetings scheduled for the city today. The path to your weekend is unobstructed.
The National Weather Service predicts that today will bring a 30% chance of showers, and a high temperature of 53 degrees. The Farmers’ Almanac starts a new, multi-day series with a prediction of “squalls Great Lakes area.”
Yesterday’s better prediction: NWS, again. It’s been a bad run for the long-range planning of the FA.
City, Development
A City-University Technology Park in Whitewater
by JOHN ADAMS •
On Sunday, the Janesville Gazette published a story on a proposed joint technology park between the city and University of Wisconsin-Whitewater.
Arguments in favor of the part include new jobs for researchers, but far more so, a way to offer businesses a reason to locate in Whitewater. The principal argument against is likely to be the cost of the venture, estimated at eleven million dollars.
See, City, university proposing technology park for a solid summary of the proposal.
Eleven million dollars seems like a lot of money, but it may not be the biggest obstacle a university-connected technology park in Whitewater would face.
Missing in the proposal is a serious acknowledgment of the cultural opposition that the university finds within our city. Candidly, we’re scarcely one city at all – we’re a city with a campus inside, a campus variously scorned, suspected, ignored, and only occasionally embraced.
This is our condition now, with the university committed, fundamentally, to a teaching mission. We have had little success with harmony now, and yet our municipal administration proposes a significant program with little awareness of how poorly received the plan may be.
(When some university officials ignore these challenges, I am reminded of the difference between being a class in oneself and a class for oneself.
I see also that, in the Gazette, Randy Marnocha, vice chancellor for administrative affairs at UW-Whitewater, talks of the benefits of the proposal. I am nonetheless reminded that the same administrator saw benefit in a joint municipal-university court. See, Joint Court Could be Just the Ticket. I saw no gain in a joint court, as it was legally impermissible. An unfeasible plan brings no benefit – see my post on the joint court, Whitewater Common Council Meeting for 9/2: The Joint Court Proposal.)
We have a municipal administration that calls for a technology park with a necessary university connection, yet seriously suggests that re-zoning to accommodate students in one part of the city requires greater restrictions elsewhere.
The idea of a net gain in students off-campus is just intolerable to a loud minority – and the administration appeases rather than enforces to satisfy this constituency.
(No one sensible questions a right of quiet enjoyment; does anyone sensible think that the city’s approach has been the right one?)
I would not oppose a tech park, if it were funded soundly. (That’s a big condition, as it should be.) I would, however, be surprised if the changes that a technology park would bring to the city would be well-received by those few who enjoying being big fish in our small, still pond. A large expansion of a professional, technology-industry class within the city would have a profound influence on life here. I would welcome it, but others would not react so favorably.
Some of our present leaders – no matter what they think of themselves – would be held to a much higher standard if we had a large tech-economy. One need only look to cities with thriving upper-middle class tech professionals to see that the business as usual approach here would be intolerable to them. What passes for a clever municipal approach just wouldn’t work.
Unlike a small, obstinate, native faction (perhaps a thousand of fourteen-thousand), no one coming to a technology park will be sold on the idea that it’s reasonable to defer to Whitewater’s peculiar standards.
A technology park is unrealistic in a city with a loud minority already ill-at-ease with its campus. A proposal like this ignores our current culture, and for that reason alone will likely prove unviable. There are barriers greater than money in our way.
