FREE WHITEWATER

The Whitewater School Board’s Decision on Early Fall Instruction: 4 Points

Updates, afternoon of 7.28.20: (1) I’ve added a recording of the 7.27.20 meeting. The best record is a recording. (2) A reader emailed to ask where I stand on recent pandemic-related public actions. On masks, I supported the city’s ordinance (to take effect 8.1) as an unfortunate necessity to preserve safe mobility in the marketplace. On a one-month, mostly virtual start to the school year, I supported that proposal, but believe that this contentious issue will fade as the course of the pandemic becomes clearer. (The board discussion has an independent value as a cultural indicator. That wasn’t the proposal’s purpose, of course, but one topic may yield many insights.)

Original post follows: 

At last night’s meeting of the Whitewater Unified School District’s board, the seven-member board voted 5-2 to begin a mostly virtual program for the first two weeks of September, and 7-0 for a mask requirement in the Whitewater Schools. I’ve written previously about a recorded focus group and the district administration’s proposal for the fall semester. See Whitewater Schools’ Community Focus Group, 7.8.20 and The Whitewater Unified School District’s Proposed Fall Instructional Plans.

A few remarks —

 1. The Pandemic. So America faces a pandemic of a seriousness about which some residents cannot agree. Agreement or disagreement today will be settled by conditions months from now. Particular claims today – maneuvers one way or another – will be decided (if at all) only over time.

 2. Engagement and Intensity. It’s possible, but unlikely, that a few intense commenters last night represented – by manner and forcefulness – a majority of the district’s population. Unlikely: most Wisconsinites are more reserved. Others – not participating – may have shared similar views, but less passionately, and so those who spoke were not truly representative of many others. Intensity, however, is not perseverance. People who have by inaction become alienated from their institutions are more likely – by inertia – to stay alienated from their institutions. See Engagement and Engagement-Engagement.

Reacting to every moment and comment with anything other than sangfroid is an overreaction. The remarks of the moment will change little in this situation. The pandemic will work an attrition that makes momentary maneuvering one way or another insignificant by comparison.

The default position to calm argumentation should be an intellectual reply; the default position to hostility should be firm resolution. This latter approach is easier said than done. It’s a good guess that some board members have not during their tenures encountered this kind of intensity.

3. Factionalized. For many years, Whitewater’s political culture rested on the assumption that the city was a center-right place, and so a few conservatives of similar disposition shaped policy as they saw fit. Two things have changed since the Great Recession: there are more center-left residents (at least within the city proper) and there has been a slowly-formed split within conservatives in the area. A new faction of conservatives may sometimes align with older ones on particular points, but they are less interested in the daily workings of local government, and much less interested in taking guidance from others, including older residents.

(These older conservatives, and the children of the last generation’s more prominent ones, are a waning force: it’s both the newer type of conservatives in the area and the liberal voters in the city who have come to play a more significant role. Older residents look to the names they remember, but there’s a new class that simply doesn’t care about those names.) 

The gap between politics within the city and in the rest of the smaller towns that comprise the district has grown wider over the last decade, and will continue to do so. Some school district disputes simply reflect the widened gap between city and towns.

4. Asides —

A three-minute comment period should mean three minutes.

Raising one’s voice only works in person (if at all); it sounds ludicrous on video or audio (and becomes the stuff of jokes and derisive viral memes).

On a list of nearby cities (that more one than one person on the conference call mentioned), only Whitewater has a (relatively large) public university. That alone makes Whitewater unlike those cities (in social interaction, economic needs, etc). If Whitewater is not like the cities nearby, then she’s certainly not like smaller towns that comprise the rest of the Whitewater Unified School District.

The Zoom chat box that the district provided during the session only highlighted the gap between factions within the district.

A rough night, one might say, but we’re rougher times than a single night ahead.

Daily Bread for 7.28.20

Good morning.

Tuesday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of eighty-three.  Sunrise is 5:43 AM and sunset 8:18 PM, for 14h 35m 20s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing gibbous with 60.9% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

Whitewater’s Finance Committee meets via audiovisual conferencing at 4:30 PM.

 On this day in 1945, during thick fog a U.S. Army B-25 bomber crashes into the 79th floor of the Empire State Building killing 14 and injuring 26.

Recommended for reading in full —
Tom Jackman and Carol D. Leonnig report National Guard commander says police suddenly moved on Lafayette Square protesters, used ‘excessive force’ before Trump visit:

An Army National Guard commander who witnessed protesters forcibly removed from Lafayette Square last month is contradicting claims by the attorney general and the Trump administration that they did not speed up the clearing to make way for the president’s photo opportunity minutes later.
A new statement by Adam DeMarco, an Iraq veteran who now serves as a major in the D.C. National Guard, also casts doubt on the claims by acting Park Police Chief Gregory Monahan that violence by protesters spurred Park Police to clear the area at that time with unusually aggressive tactics. DeMarco said that “demonstrators were behaving peacefully” and that tear gas was deployed in an “excessive use of force.”

DeMarco backs up law enforcement officials who told The Washington Post they believed the clearing operation would happen after the 7 p.m. curfew that night — but it was dramatically accelerated after Attorney General William P. Barr and others appeared in the park around 6 p.m. Monahan has said the operation was conducted so that a fence might be erected around the park. DeMarco said the fencing materials did not arrive until 9 p.m. — hours after Barr told the Park Police to expand the perimeter — and the fence wasn’t built until later that night.

 Matt Zapotosky and Karoun Demirjian report What to expect when Barr is questioned by the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday:

Attorney General William P. Barr will tell the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday that President Trump has not inappropriately intervened in Justice Department business — even though Barr has more than once moved in criminal cases to help the president’s allies — and he will defend the administration’s response to civil unrest in the country, according to a copy of his opening statement.

Barr, according to the statement, will take a defiant posture as he testifies before the panel for the first time since Democrats took control of it, alleging that they have attempted to “discredit” him since he vowed to investigate the 2016 FBI probe of possible coordination between Russia and the Trump campaign, and the media has been unfair in covering unrest. He is expected to face critical questioning on his response to anti-police brutality protests across the nation, his controversial interventions in high-profile cases involving allies of Trump and many other matters.

According to a Democratic committee counsel, lawmakers will ask Barr about his role dispatching federal agents to respond to anti-police-brutality protests that have at times grown violent — first in D.C. and more recently, in Portland, Ore.

Your new lab partner: A mobile robot chemist:

more >>

Engagement and Engagement-Engagement

Sometimes, as a matter of emphasis, people repeat a word – so a big tree becomes a big-big tree, and something sweet becomes sweet-sweet. The repetition of the adjective suggests an exceptional thing – more intense or more significant.

In this way, there might be both engagement and engagement-engagement. In this first situation, there’s some involvement in an issue or discussion; in the second situation, there’s ongoing involvement beyond the moment.

One can offer a guess about Whitewater, from the presence of a same-ten-person problem for government participation: a controversy might led to engagement with government on an issue, but it may not lead to engagement-engagement (that is, longterm, consistent involvement).

The best indicator of whether someone will respond to government action is whether he or she has responded consistently in the past. That man or woman has a track record; declarations of ongoing action from others who have not engaged consistently are merely promissory.

Daily Bread for 7.27.20

Good morning.

Monday in Whitewater will be partly cloudy with a high of eighty-one.  Sunrise is 5:42 AM and sunset 8:20 PM, for 14h 37m 26s of daytime.  The moon is in its first quarter with 49.5% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

 Whitewater’s Urban Forestry Commission meets visual conferencing at 4:30 PM, and the Whitewater Unified School Board meets via audiovisual conferencing at 7 PM.

 On this day in 1940, The animated short A Wild Hare is released, introducing the character of Bugs Bunny.

Recommended for reading in full —

 Ron Brownstein writes Trump’s Portland Offensive Fits a Long Pattern:

Trump’s alarms about “angry mobs” and “violent mayhem” in Democratic cities might allow him to recapture some Republican-leaning white suburbanites and energize his rural and small-town support, analysts in both parties told me. But as I’ve written before, his belligerent tone simultaneously risks hardening the opposition he’s facing from the many suburban voters who feel that he’s exposing them to more danger—both in his response to the policing protests and his unrelenting push to reopen the economy despite the coronavirus’s resurgence. In last week’s national Quinnipiac University poll, just over seven in 10 white voters holding at least a four-year college degree disapproved of Trump’s handling of both race relations and the outbreak.

The larger political implication of these battles is to deepen the sense that the nation is hardening into antagonistic camps separated by an imaginary border that circles all of the major population centers, dividing the metropolitan core within from the less densely settled places beyond.

Trump is determined to widen that trench. He is trying to rally red America by portraying blue cities as a threat, and then positioning himself as the human wall against them. Until now, Trump has advanced that divisive vision through rhetoric denouncing cities and through policies that cost them money and influence, such as eliminating the federal deduction for state and local taxes, trying to block Justice Department grants for cities that don’t fully cooperate with federal immigration authorities, and his renewed efforts to strip undocumented immigrants from the census.

The Washington Post editorial board writes Schools are moving toward closing for the fall. That is not their fault:

The White House has made it unmistakably clear that it wants schools to open this year with full in-person instruction, and that nothing — least of all the science — should stand in the way. But the actual decisions on whether to allow children back into the classroom are thankfully being made not by a president hellbent on making a political point, but by school officials who are listening to public health experts and consulting with members of their communities. Many of them are coming to the reluctant conclusion that the failure to contain the novel coronavirus — something that actually is the responsibility of President Trump’s administration — makes it unwise to return children to the classroom.

….

 If Mr. Trump wanted to take constructive action to get children back in the classroom, he would put in place the testing and other safeguards needed to control the virus rather than just browbeating the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention into becoming a cheerleader for his political agenda or trotting out his education secretary with absurd theories of how children actually block the virus.

Plant-based meats: More global food giants now developing plant protein alternatives:

more >>

Daily Bread for 7.26.20

Good morning.

Sunday in Whitewater will be partly cloudy with a high of eighty-nine.  Sunrise is 5:41 AM and sunset 8:21 PM, for 14h 39m 29s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 38.2% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

 On this day in 1775, the office that would later become the United States Post Office Department is established by the Second Continental Congress.

Recommended for reading in full —

 David A. Fahrenthold, Joshua Partlow, and Jonathan O’Connell report Spin, deride, attack: How Trump’s handling of Trump University presaged his presidency:

The judge was out to get him, he said. So was that prosecutor in New York, whom he called a dopey loser on a witch hunt. So were his critics, who he said were all liars. Even some of his own underlings had failed him — bad people, it turned out. He said he didn’t know them.

Now, he was trying to attack his way out, breaking all the unwritten rules about the way a man of his position should behave. The secret to his tactic: “I don’t care” about breaking the rules, Trump said at a news conference. “Why antagonize? Because I don’t care.”

That was 2016. He was talking about a real estate school called Trump University.

Trump University, which shut down in 2011 after multiple investigations and student complaints, was treated as a joke by many of Trump’s political opponents — much as they treated Trump Steaks or Trump Vodka. But to those who knew the school well, it wasn’t a joke.

The saga of Trump University showed how far Trump would go to deny, rather than fix, a problem, they said — a tactic they have now seen him reuse as president many times, including now, in the face of a worsening pandemic. For months, President Trump promised something wonderful but extremely unlikely — that the virus would soon disappear.

John Cassidy writes America Is a Country Besieged by Its Own President:

On Wednesday, Tom Ridge, a veteran Republican who served as the governor of Pennsylvania and as the first Secretary of Homeland Security, said that the agency wasn’t established “to be the President’s personal militia.” Ridge added, “Had I been governor even now, I would welcome the opportunity to work with any federal agency to reduce crime or lawlessness in any of the cities. But . . . it would be a cold day in hell before I would consent to a unilateral, uninvited intervention into one of my cities.”

In Chicago, Mayor Lori Lightfoot said that the city would gladly accept federal assistance in fighting crime, but she also issued a warning. “We welcome actual partnership, but we do not welcome dictatorship,” she said. “We do not welcome authoritarianism, and we do not welcome the unconstitutional arrests and detainments of our residents, and that is something I will not tolerate.”

These developments suggest that America as a whole isn’t failing—not yet, anyway. But its system of government, its stated values, and its claims to greatness are all under siege by a President who lacks the moral compass, self-doubt, and respect for historical norms that would restrain another leader.

Why One Man Is Walking Around the World With His Dog:

more >>

Daily Bread for 7.25.20

Good morning.

Saturday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of eighty-eight.  Sunrise is 5:40 AM and sunset 8:22 PM, for 14h 41m 31s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 27.4% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

 On this day in 1999, Robin Yount becomes the first player inducted to the Baseball Hall of Fame in a Brewer’s jersey.

Recommended for reading in full —

Luke Nozicka, Bryan Lowry, and Cortlynn Stark report Barr’s claim of 200 arrests in Kansas City is debunked (‘KC arrests Barr wrongly cited were made months earlier, led to no new federal charges’):

When U.S. Attorney General William Barr announced Wednesday the expansion of federal anti-crime initiatives, he baffled officials in Kansas City with a single statement.

“Just to give you an idea of what’s possible, the FBI went in very strong into Kansas City and within two weeks we’ve had 200 arrests,” Barr said of apprehensions made as part of a new effort called Operation Legend.

But after inquiries from The Star and pushback from local officials, a senior Justice Department official clarified Barr’s comments, saying the 200 figure included state and FBI arrests in joint operations dating back to December as part of another operation, Relentless Pursuit.

Barr’s false claim, livestreamed by the White House, raised questions about the Justice Department’s trustworthiness. And the point Barr apparently was illustrating only grew shakier Thursday as officials in Kansas City clarified further that the arrests that did occur resulted in no new federal charges — with the exception of one case announced earlier this week.

 Dan Alexander and Michela Tinera report How Donald Trump moved millions from his campaign donors to his private business:

Donald Trump has not given a dime to his reelection campaign, opting instead to fund the entire effort with his donors’ money. His business, meanwhile, has continued to charge the campaign for things like food, lodging and rent. The result is that $2.2 million of contributions from other people has turned into $2.2 million of revenue for Trump.

And that’s just counting the money flowing directly through the president’s campaign. His reelection apparatus also includes two joint fundraising committees, which work with the Republican Party to raise money for Trump. Since he took office, those entities—named Trump Victory and the Trump Make America Great Again Committee—have funneled another $2.3 million into the president’s private business, according to a review of Federal Election Commission records. Then there’s the Republican National Committee, which has spent an additional $2.4 million at Trump properties. Add it all up, and the president, working in concert with the party he leads, has helped push $6.9 million into his businesses since taking office.

It’s a meaningful sum, even for a large business. Consider the payments to Trump National Doral, the president’s golf resort in Miami. In 2017, Trump’s first year leading the country, revenues at Doral dropped from $88 million to $75 million, dragging profits (measured as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) down from $12.4 million to just $4.3 million. The next year, the RNC, which had spent just $3,000 at the property in 2017, upped its expenditures to $603,000. That helped give a slight boost to the business, which recorded 2018 profits of $9.7 million, according to a spokesperson for the Trump Organization.

Video from Space – Weekly Highlights for the Week of July 19, 2020:

more >>

Daily Bread for 7.24.20

Good morning.

Friday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of eighty-four.  Sunrise is 5:39 AM and sunset 8:23 PM, for 14h 43m 30s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 17.5% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

 On this day in 1969, Apollo 11 splashes down safely in the Pacific Ocean.

Recommended for reading in full —

Anne Applebaum writes The president is deploying the kind of performative authoritarianism that Vladimir Putin pioneered:

The very idea seems, on the face of it, sheer madness. In Portland, Oregon, federal security officers dressed for combat—wearing jungle-camouflage uniforms with unclear markings, carrying heavy weapons, using batons and tear gas—are patrolling the streets, making random arrests, throwing people into unmarked vans. The officers do not come from institutions that specialize in political crowd control. Instead, they come from Customs and Border Protection, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the Transportation Security Administration, and the Coast Guard. These are people with experience patrolling the border, frisking airline passengers, and deporting undocumented immigrants—exactly the wrong sort of experience needed to carry out the delicate task of policing an angry political protest.

….

Students of modern dictatorship will find these tactics wearily familiar. Russian President Vladimir Putin, whom Trump admires, has deployed performative authoritarianism, alongside other tools, in order to keep himself in power for many years now. In 2014, during a political crisis in Ukraine, he created an elaborate media narrative that equated Ukrainian democracy protesters with 1940s fascists. Russian state television showed scenes of violence over and over again—scenes that Putin himself had helped create, first by encouraging the former Ukrainian president to shoot at demonstrators, and then by invading the country. He sent troops in unmarked uniforms—the infamous “little green men”—into Crimea and eventually eastern Ukraine to “dominate” the situation, to use Trump’s own word for his tactics in Portland. Or at least that was the way it was meant to look on TV.

Lt. Gen. (retired) Mark Hertling writes I helped build a police force in Iraq. We refused to dress them in camo:

We were rapidly expanding our recruiting and training of future Iraqi police officers so we could put thousands in the cities quickly, but the interior minister — the Baghdad official charged with growing the nascent police force — couldn’t get us the large number of uniforms we needed for those we were graduating. The minister asked if we would accept camouflage outfits instead of police uniforms for the graduates, and he asked if we would also accept unmarked pickup trucks for service as police cruisers.

“Tell him, ‘Hell, no,’” the MP commander told me emphatically. When I asked why, he explained the history of the blue police uniform, as well as the psychological role that a uniform plays in law enforcement. The traditional “blues” started with the London “bobbies” of the early 1800s, whose uniforms were designed to distinguish the British police force from the British military. Our nation’s first organized police, in New York, continued this tradition in the 1850s, numerous other American cities followed suit, and now most nations associate the police officer with blue uniforms.

Myriad studies have shown interesting results: For example, some research shows citizens adjust behaviors when someone wearing a police uniform is nearby; others show that police uniforms are most likely to “induce feelings of safety” when compared to other uniforms or civilian clothes, and those wearing a blue uniform receive a high rate of cooperation when asked to perform a task. Wearing camouflage uniforms, our division MP commander said, would send the wrong message, especially in a society where neither the U.S. nor the Iraqi military was yet trusted by the population.

How CBS News covered the Apollo 11 splashdown:

more >>

Donald Trump’s Niece on Her Bestselling Family Account

After the Trump family went to court to stop the book—and lost—it was published last week and has reportedly sold a million copies. This memoir/psychological dissection, “Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World’s Most Dangerous Man,” is a harrowing account of a man and a clan shaped by ego, rivalry, the pursuit of wealth, and profound pathology.

Mary Trump’s depiction of her uncle as a broken human being—broken by his father, Fred, a ruthless patriarch with sociopathic traits—is more explanatory than revelatory. She doesn’t show us a Trump we haven’t already seen. But she explains how and why he became a person more concerned about his TV ratings than the deaths of 140,000 fellow Americans.

 

The Whitewater Unified School District’s Proposed Fall Instructional Plans

Last night (7.22), the Whitewater Unified School District held a virtual meeting to describe a fall instructional proposal to be presented to the district’s school board on 7.27.20. The meeting was interrupted, and so the district published today (7.23) a video describing the proposal. Embedded above is that video presentation. (There was an earlier, recorded parent focus group on 7.8.20, about which I have posted. See Whitewater Schools’ Community Focus Group, 7.8.20)

Generally, the proposal calls for primarily virtual instruction from September 1 to 29, with limited face-to-face instruction (including orientation before the school year begins).  (Video, beginning at 9:10.) There would be re-evaluation thereafter, with the hope of increasing face-to-face instruction time. All students would be provided during this time a Chromebook model varying by grade level, with technology support.

There are choices before the board about food service, with three options running from in-classroom meals, and meals for virtual learners. (Video, 20:40.)

There’s an effort – still in planning – for after-school childcare options. (Video, 24:10.)

A tiered athletic plan has begun already, one that extends into the period of this proposal. (Video 30:55.)

A few remarks —

. 1. Uncertainty Calls for Caution. It’s an understatement to say that these are difficult times, and a public health threat is made worse for Whitewater by existing economic problems. This small community has, among its residents, different populations, with different daily occupations, living close to each other. For the community to fare well during a pandemic, a cautious approach is justified. It’s reason, not fear, that recommends this approach. A rushed return would not evince strength, but instead weakness.

. 2. Provison of Food. Which food-service model of the three the district recommends matters less than that adequate nutrition is issued in safe condition. It’s also necessary, as the plan provides, that virtual learners receive their school meals. That accomplishment alone would be a gain to the community — public schools in Whitewater play a critical role in assuring children are properly fed.

3. The School Board. While a cautious approach (like this one) is rational, whether this school board will embrace that approach in the face of pressure is a bet a sensible person would be reluctant to wager. These board members have not had to make a decision this important during their tenures. 

 4. Open Government. It’s regrettable that the community presentation last night was interrupted, but the best approach is always to review a video (or document) fully oneself. The recording from today gives residents an opportunity to do so.