FREE WHITEWATER

Author Archive for JOHN ADAMS

Sunshine Week 2019

It’s Sunshine Week in America: a seven-day focus from the American Society of News Editors and Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press on “access to public information and what it means for you and your community.”

One doesn’t have to be a reporter (and bloggers, for example, are not reporters) to understand the importance of open government.  Government in a free society is nothing less – but nothing more – than a human institution established for limited purposes and depending on the consent of the governed.

It’s true, as the Associated Press writes, that Town by Town, Local Journalism Is Dying in Plain Sight.  This is as true in the Whitewater area as it is in other places. The Register is inconsequential, the Milton Courier just gave up its building and will go the way of the Register, and the Daily Union shrinks by the day.

So the local press is dying, and however tragic this demise, much of it has been self-inflicted.  Too many reporters and publishers have abandoned the serious inquiry of political authority for glad-handing coverage of local politicians (a few of whom carry on as though entitled by God’s will).

Local news these recent years has not been too hard on political authority; it has been too soft.  The news is not ‘fake’ merely because politicians dislike it; on the contrary, it’s more likely to be fake when politicians like it very much.

Those of us who grew up on inquisitive, diligent newspaper reporting find present-day newspapers nearly unrecognizable in comparison.

In our local environment, the best record of meetings comes not from the few remaining lapdog reporters, but from full recordings of those meetings.  See The Disorder Nearby.

Along the way, on the basis of a prior authority to that of politicians and local notables, one makes one’s way as best one can.

Daily Bread for 3.10.19

Good morning.

Sunday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of thirty-seven.  Sunrise is 7:14 AM and sunset 6:55 PM, for 11h 41m 37s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 14% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1864, the Red River campaign begins in Louisiana:

The Red River Campaign took place in Louisiana and Texas. At a crucial moment in the campaign, Wisconsin Captain Joseph Bailey (1827-1867) of Wisconsin Dells freed 60 stranded transport ships and their accompanying ironclad gunboats as Confederate troops approached to capture them. The 8th, 14th, 23rd, 29th and 33rd Wisconsin Infantry regiments and the 1st Wisconsin Light Artillery participated in the Red River Campaign. The Red River expedition lasted until May 22.

Recommended for reading in full:

  Ron Brownstein writes Trump Settles on His Reelection Message (“I’ll protect you” is the new “I alone can fix it”):

In his marathon speech to a gathering of conservative activists last weekend, Donald Trump unloaded more than 16,000 words, according to the official White House transcript.

But amid all the meandering and asides, the belittling taunts (“Little Shifty Schiff” for Democratic Representative Adam Schiff) and geysers of grievance, Trump may have synthesized the essence of his reelection strategy in just three words toward the back end of his two-hour harangue: “I’ll protect you.”

With that concise phrase, Trump revealed volumes about his view of the electorate and the coalition that he hopes will carry him to a second term. The comment underscored his determination to convince his followers of a two-stage proposition: First, that they are “under siege,” as he put it, by an array of forces that he presented as either hostile to their interests or contemptuous of their values, and second, that only he can shield them from those threats.

That dark and martial message shows that Trump continues to prioritize energizing his core supporters—blue-collar, older, and nonurban whites uneasy about demographic, cultural, and economic change—even at the price of further alienating voters dismayed or disgusted by his behavior as president.

  Margaret Sullivan contends It’s time — high time — to take Fox News’s destructive role in America seriously:

Given First Amendment protections, Fox News can do pretty much what it wants on the air. It can shrug at Hannity’s excesses. It can allow Tucker Carlson’s misleading rants on immigrants and crime. It can constantly undermine special counsel Robert S. Mueller III’s investigation of Trump.

….

What Fox News has become is destructive. To state the obvious: Democracy, if it’s going to function, needs to be based on a shared set of facts, and the news media’s role is to seek out and deliver those facts.

And, of course, to double down on its mission, described aptly by my colleague Greg Sargent: “Fox News is fundamentally in the business of spreading disinformation, as opposed to conservative reportage.” And that disinformation “is plainly about deceiving millions into believing that core functionings of our government — whether law enforcement or congressional oversight — no longer have any legitimacy.”

Playing Instruments Made From Ice:

Film: Tuesday, March 12th, 12:30 PM @ Seniors in the Park, Bohemian Rhapsody

This Tuesday, March 12th at 12:30 PM, there will be a showing of Bohemian Rhapsody @ Seniors in the Park, in the Starin community building:

Bohemian Rhapsody (Biography/Drama/Musical)

Tuesday, March 12, 12:30 pm
Rated PG-13; 2 hours, 14 minutes

The story of the legacy rock band, Queen, and its infamous lead singer, Freddy Mercury and his struggles, from immigrant origins and sexual orientation, to eventual legendary rock status.  Nominated for 5 Oscars, the film won four awards: Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role (Rami Malek), Best Achievement in Film Editing (John Ottman), Best Achievement in Sound Editing (John Warhurst  & Nina Hartstone), and Best Achievement in Sound Mixing (Paul Massey, Tim Cavagin, and John Casali).

One can find more information about Bohemian Rhapsody at the Internet Movie Database.

Enjoy.

 

Daily Bread for 3.9.19

Good morning.

Saturday in Whitewater will rainy in the afternoon with a daytime high of thirty-eight.  Sunrise is 6:15 AM and sunset 5:54 PM, for 11h 38m 49s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 8.1% of its visible disk illuminated.

There is a scheduled forum for common council candidates at 10 AM, and another for school board candidates at 1 PM, at Whitewater’s city hall.

On this day in 1862, two ironclad warships (each under steam power) fight for the first time:

The major significance of the battle is that it was the first meeting in combat of ironclad warships, i.e., USS Monitor and CSS Virginia. The Confederate fleet consisted of the ironclad ram Virginia (built from the remnants of the under-construction steam frigate USS Merrimack, newest warship for the United States Navy / Union Navy) and several supporting vessels. On the first day of battle, they were opposed by several conventional, wooden-hulled ships of the Union Navy. On that day, Virginia was able to destroy two ships of the federal flotilla, USS Congress and USS Cumberland, and was about to attack a third, USS Minnesota, which had run aground. However, the action was halted by darkness and falling tide

….

During the night, however, the ironclad Monitor had arrived and had taken a position to defend Minnesota. When Virginia approached, Monitor intercepted her. The two ironclads fought for about three hours, with neither being able to inflict significant damage on the other. The duel ended indecisively, Virginia returning to her home at the Gosport Navy Yard for repairs and strengthening, and Monitor to her station defending Minnesota

Recommended for reading in full:

  Paul C. Light considers How the House should investigate the Trump administration (“Lessons from the most important House probes since WWII”):

  1. Longer investigations had roughly equal levels of moderate to very significant impact as shorter (33 percent and 32 percent respectively), but longer investigations produced a higher count of very significant impact than shorter (three to one).
  2. Bipartisan investigations had twice the impact of partisan investigations (50 percent to 26 percent).
  3. Broader investigations had more than three times the impact of narrower investigations (67 percent to 18 percent).
  4. Thorough investigations had almost six times the impact of narrower investigations (62 percent to 11 percent).
  5. Investigations with high freedom had 10 times the impact of investigations with less freedom (60 percent to six percent).
  6. Highly visible investigations had twice the impact than of visible investigations (40 percent to 18 percent).
  7. Investigations led by experienced chairs had almost twice the impact of investigations with less experienced chairs (50 percent to 28 percent).
  8. Serious investigations had more than four times the impact of less serious investigations (53 percent to 12 percent).
  9. High- and low-leverage investigations had roughly equal levels of impact (33 percent to 30 percent), but high-leverage produced a higher count of very significant investigations (seven to three).
  10. Durable investigations had almost five times the impact of less durable investigations (70 to 15 percent).

  Flying Squirrels:

Daily Bread for 3.8.19

Good morning.

Friday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of thirty-eight.  Sunrise is 6:17 AM and sunset 5:53 PM, for 11h 35m 53s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing crescent with 3.1% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1917, Russia’s February Revolution begins, leading to the abdication of Czar Nicholas II.

Recommended for reading in full:

  Helaine Olen writes House Democrats are afraid to investigate Trump’s family. They are mistaken:

Politico reports that many House Democrats are expressing skittishness when it comes to looking into the allegedly illegal behavior of President Trump’s family members. The reason: They believe any targeting of Trump’s children or their families, no matter the reason, will increase voter sympathy for the president.

Au contraire. There is no better sign of how things have gone wrong for the country of 2019 than the prominence of Trump’s family members in our body politic and business life. Calling the Trump clan to account is a necessary step in making things right.

We can start with son Donald Trump Jr., who has already testified in sessions closed to the public and press about his role in the 2016 presidential campaign. If he could sign a check to repay then-presidential lawyer Michael Cohen for the money he allegedly advanced to get Stormy Daniels to stay quiet in the weeks before the 2016 election about her affair with his father, surely he’s up for the task of explaining to the American people exactly what he thought he was purchasing.

Thoughts on Manafort’s relatively light sentence (far less than federal advisory guidelines):

  SpaceX’s Crew Dragon capsule is heading back to Earth – a live stream is below:

The spacecraft is scheduled to splash down in the Atlantic Ocean, near Florida’s eastern coast.

Foxconn Roundup

From the beginning, it should have been clear to any reasonable person that the Foxconn project was ill-conceived, and destructive of nearby homeowners’ rights. Yet for all the bad news about that fraudulent project, there is still more bad news to relate.

John Schmid reports Wisconsin might not get a Foxconn plant of any size, analysts say:

Back in 2017, there was no ambiguity over what Foxconn Technology Group would build in Wisconsin. It was spelled out in a 29-page contract signed by then-Gov. Scott Walker and Foxconn’s top executives.

The world’s biggest manufacturer of made-in-China consumer electronics agreed to a sprawling “Generation 10.5” manufacturing campus — industry-speak for a monumental industrial facility capable of producing outsized flat-screen monitors used in the biggest TVs and liquid-crystal displays.

And now?

Veteran analysts of the flat-panel industry, which is based entirely in Asia, are openly skeptical that even the smaller cousin of that massive plant — what’s known as “Generation 6” —  will be built in Wisconsin.

Lawrence Tabak writes Where to now with Foxconn? It won’t leave Wisconsin, but it won’t build what it promised:

When reached for an update this past week, industry expert Bob O’Brien of Display Supply Chain Consultants spoke of the changing dynamics driving Foxconn’s shifting plans for Wisconsin. The market is glutted by flat screens. He said a new Foxconn LCD plant anywhere appears unlikely. Even Foxconn’s 10.5 plant being built in China has been put on hold until flat panel pricing improves.

….

When reached for an update this past week, industry expert Bob O’Brien of Display Supply Chain Consultants spoke of the changing dynamics driving Foxconn’s shifting plans for Wisconsin. The market is glutted by flat screens. He said a new Foxconn LCD plant anywhere appears unlikely. Even Foxconn’s 10.5 plant being built in China has been put on hold until flat panel pricing improves.

Previously10 Key Articles About FoxconnFoxconn as Alchemy: Magic Multipliers,  Foxconn Destroys Single-Family HomesFoxconn Devours Tens of Millions from State’s Road Repair BudgetThe Man Behind the Foxconn ProjectA Sham News Story on Foxconn, Another Pig at the TroughEven Foxconn’s Projections Show a Vulnerable (Replaceable) WorkforceFoxconn in Wisconsin: Not So High Tech After All, Foxconn’s Ambition is Automation, While Appeasing the Politically Ambitious, Foxconn’s Shabby Workplace ConditionsFoxconn’s Bait & SwitchFoxconn’s (Overwhelmingly) Low-Paying JobsThe Next Guest SpeakerTrump, Ryan, and Walker Want to Seize Wisconsin Homes to Build Foxconn Plant, Foxconn Deal Melts Away“Later This Year,” Foxconn’s Secret Deal with UW-Madison, Foxconn’s Predatory Reliance on Eminent Domain, Foxconn: Failure & FraudFoxconn Roundup: Desperately Ill Edition Foxconn Roundup: Indiana Layoffs & Automation Everywhere, Foxconn Roundup: Outside Work and Local Land, Foxconn Couldn’t Even Meet Its Low First-Year Goal, Foxconn Talks of Folding Wisconsin Manufacturing Plans, WISGOP Assembly Speaker Vos Hopes You’re StupidLost Homes and Land, All Over a Foxconn Fantasy, Laughable Spin as Industrial Policy, Foxconn: The ‘State Visit Project,’ ‘Inside Wisconsin’s Disastrous $4.5 Billion Deal With Foxconn,,’ Foxconn: When the Going Gets Tough…, and The Amazon-New York Deal, Like the Foxconn Deal, Was Bad Policy.

Daily Bread for 3.7.19

Good morning.

Thursday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of twenty-six.  Sunrise is 6:19 AM and sunset 5:52 PM, for 11h 32m 59s of daytime.  The moon is new with 0.6% of its visible disk illuminated.

Whitewater’s Landmarks Commission is scheduled to meet at 6 PM.

On this day in 1876, Alexander Graham Bell patents the telephone:

Bell’s patent 174,465, was issued to Bell on March 7, 1876, by the U.S. Patent Office. Bell’s patent covered “the method of, and apparatus for, transmitting vocal or other sounds telegraphically … by causing electrical undulations, similar in form to the vibrations of the air accompanying the said vocal or other sound”[82][N 15] Bell returned to Boston the same day and the next day resumed work, drawing in his notebook a diagram similar to that in Gray’s patent caveat.

 

 

 

Recommended for reading in full:

Damian Paletta reports The federal deficit ballooned at start of new fiscal year, up 77 percent from a year before:

The federal budget deficit ballooned rapidly in the first four months of the fiscal year amid falling tax revenue and higher spending, the Treasury Department said Tuesday, posing a new challenge for the White House and Congress as they prepare for a number of budget battles.

The deficit grew 77 percent in the first four months of fiscal 2019 compared with the same period one year before, Treasury said.

The total deficit for the four-month period was $310 billion, Treasury said, up from $176 billion for the same period one year earlier.

“It’s big tax cuts combined with big increases in spending when they already had big deficits,” said former Senate Budget Committee chairman Kent Conrad (D-N.D.). “So guess what, it’s craziness!”

William Frey writes A vast majority of counties showed increased Democratic support in 2018 House election:

When Democrats took 40 congressional districts from Republicans in the 2018 election, the House of Representatives experienced what many considered to be a blue wave. What does this shift mean for the 2020 presidential election? To get a better sense of this, the following analysis examines the 2018 House votes distributed across the nation’s more than 3,100 counties. This provides a more fine-grained geographic assessment of how the 2018 House support for Democrats compared with votes in the 2016 presidential election.

From this perspective, the Democratic wave is all encompassing: 83 percent of the voting population lived in counties where support for Democrats has improved since 2016. This increased Democratic support was not confined to traditional Democratic base counties. It occurred in suburbs, smaller metropolitan and rural counties, and most noticeably, in counties with concentrations of older, native-born and white residents without college degrees. Moreover, at the state level, enough states flipped from Republican majorities in the 2016 presidential election to Democratic majorities in the 2018 House elections to project a 2020 Democratic Electoral College win.

  Crew Dragon docking time-lapse:

Fruitless Embrace

Free-market economist Veronique de Rugy asks Why Are Republicans Embracing Economic State Planning?:

China’s post-Mao economic boom has occurred only to the extent that the country became capitalist. With “Made in China 2025,” Beijing’s 2015 anticapitalist plan for an industrial policy under which the state would pick “winners,” China has taken a step back from capitalism. (It recently dropped the “Made in China 2025” name, though the policy remains.)

It won’t work, but China’s new industrial policy has worked one marvel — namely, scaring many American conservatives into believing that the main driver of economic growth isn’t the market but bureaucrats invested with power to control the allocation of natural and financial resources.

….

China’s economic future is bright, but only as long as it rejects large-scale industrial policy and instead recommits to competitive markets. We shouldn’t copy its recent command-and-control playbook. Rather, we should stick with the time-honored policies that have made the United States the titan to topple in the first place: free trade, competitive markets, reasonable regulations and the rule of law.

Market-based policies (policies that flourish in conditions of limited government and the rule of law) are superior solutions to the commands of government (and the predations of well-fed interests – found even in the smallest places – that selfishly manipulate government for their own aggrandizement).

Daily Bread for 3.6.19

Good morning.

Ash Wednesday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of twenty-four.  Sunrise is 6:20 AM and sunset 5:50 PM, for 11h 30m 04s of daytime.  The moon is new.

 

On this day in 1862, the 4th Wisconsin Cavalry heads south:

the 4th Wisconsin Cavalry (then an infantry unit) embarked to join the “Army of the Gulf.” It arrived below New Orleans on March 12, 1862, and landed in New Orleans on May 1. The 4th was at once assigned to active service and joined an expedition up the Mississippi River against Vicksburg in May. By June they occupied Baton Rouge, Louisiana. The troops there were employed in several successful expeditions during that winter, and remained in the area through most of the war. In June of 1862, its commander was punished for refusing to return escaping slaves to their masters (more information on this event is at Turning Points in Wisconsin History). In 1863 the unit was equipped as a Cavalry Regiment; it returned to Wisconsin in 1866.

Recommended for reading in full:

Patrick Marley and Molly Beck report In a blow to conservatives, a national business group is staying out of the Wisconsin Supreme Court race:

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce won’t pour money into this year’s state Supreme Court race, creating new challenges for conservative candidate Brian Hagedorn.

The national organization often funnels money to Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce to help conservatives in court races but won’t do so this year, according to three sources familiar with the plans.

The move comes as other conservatives signal they’re staying on the sidelines after reports about Hagedorn founding a school that can ban teachers and students in gay relationships and giving paid speeches to a legal organization that has argued in favor of anti-sodomy laws.

The Wisconsin Realtors Association last month withdrew its endorsement of Hagedorn and asked him to return an $18,000 donation. Soon afterward, longtime Republican consultants R.J. Johnson and Deb Jordahl — who have run past independent efforts to help conservatives running for the Supreme Court — wrote a column defending the Realtors’ decision to stay out of the race.

The Committee to Investigate Russia writes White House Fights Oversight:

It took just one day for President Trump to change course from saying he cooperates with everyone to attacking the House Judiciary Committee’s request for documents and information as it advances its investigation into potential obstruction of justice, corruption, and abuse of power.

The Hill:

“It’s a disgrace to our country. I’m not surprised that it’s happening. Basically, they’ve started the campaign. So the campaign begins,” Trump told reporters at the White House after signing an executive order on veterans’ suicide prevention.

“Instead of doing infrastructure, instead of doing health care, instead of doing so many things that they should be doing, they want to play games,” he continued.

(…)

The president’s remarks suggest the White House could invoke executive privilege or take other measures to shield internal documents or discussions from Democratic-led panels investigating Trump’s administration, campaign and businesses.

  Why Microwaved Grapes Explode:

The Middle Lane is a Dirt Road to Decay, Pt. 2

Last month, this site linked to media critic Margaret Sullivan’s observation that The media feel safest in the middle lane. Just ask Jeff Flake, John Kasich and Howard Schultz:

Who is the media’s middle-lane approach actually good for?

Not the public, certainly, since readers and viewers would benefit from strong viewpoints across the full spectrum of political thought, not just minor variations of the same old stuff.

See The Middle Lane is a Dirt Road to Decay.

In small towns like Whitewater, that middle lane is one of bad writing and bad policy.

Consider, for example, a press-release-pretending-to-be-a-news-story about a local business league’s annual meeting.  In State transportation chief keynotes Greater Whitewater gathering, one reads that

The GWC is an action-oriented group committed to working with citizens, elected officials and policymakers to identify, craft and implement a pro-business agenda. The agenda advances the economic, education and social policies required to energize and secure the Whitewater area’s economic future, as well as protect Whitewater’s quality of life.

Honest to goodness that paragraph reads like a press release because it is, in fact, from a press release!

It’s also laughably grandiose: no normal person could believe that the agenda of a few local conservative businessmen fulfills the what’s required for the community’s economy, schools, and society to energize and secure Whitewater’s future and quality of life. Didn’t someone who wrote these lines think, for even a moment, that it was all a bit much?

Perhaps these few stare each morning into magic mirrors and ask who’s the fairest one of all.

One wonders – truly – whether anyone at the local paper (Welch the reporter, Spangler the editor) can tell the difference between a news story and a press release, or would even ponder the topic.  This local paper’s default position isn’t reporting and thoughtful journalism: it’s whatever approximation of English words they can string together to fill the space between advertisements.

It’s the default position of a declining class of entitled men in places like Whitewater that public money should be used to fund their pet business projects despite ample evidence that economic and social conditions have grown worse over time.  Their control and manipulation of ‘community development’ hasn’t developed individual or household incomes.  See A Candid Admission from the Whitewater CDA, Reported Family Poverty in Whitewater Increased Over the Last Decade, and Private Businesses Craving Public Money.

A central planning czar could order a new truck factory to be built, and a business league can divert public money for their favored projects, but without improvement in individual or household prosperity there is no meaningful community development.

What’s occupied the default or middle position in these communities is a relationship in which a small number of pro-government businessmen, pressuring a small number of officials (or acting as officials simultaneously), with the cheering of a few sycophantic publishers, direct public money to their own goals while receiving empty praise from those officials and publishers.

This leaves the middle position as the worst lane to travel: a dirt road to decay.

Daily Bread for 3.5.19

Good morning.

Tuesday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of eighteen.  Sunrise is 6:22 AM and sunset 5:49 PM, for 11h 27m 10s of daytime.  The moon is a waning crescent with 1.3% of its visible disk illuminated.

The Whitewater Common Council meets at 6:30 PM.

The Boston Massacre takes place on this day in 1770.

Recommended for reading in full:

 

Corrinne Hess reports Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office No Longer Working With ICE:

The Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office will no longer offer information to immigration officials about people detained in the jail.

Sheriff Earnell Lucas, who took office Jan. 7, said he wants to avoid lawsuits other law enforcement agencies across the country have faced for holding inmates for up to 48 hours longer than they should have been detained so U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents could interview and possibly take custody of the inmate.

Lucas announced last week he had established a policy ensuring that absent a valid judicial warrant, information would no longer be shared with ICE.

Lucas’ policy is a shift from former Sheriff David Clarke’s administration, which not only fully cooperated with ICE, but also attempted to sign a 287(g) agreement to give deputies the authority to act as ICE representatives.

Milwaukee County was not approved for that type of an agreement after community protests. Though the neighboring Waukesha County Sheriff’s Department has signed a 287(g) agreement with the federal government.

  Glenn Kessler, Salvador Rizzo, and Meg Kelly write President Trump has made 9,014 false or misleading claims over 773 days:

Powered by his two-hour stemwinder at the Conservative Political Action Conference on March 2 — which featured more than 100 false or misleading claims — President Trump is on pace to exceed his daily quota set during his first two years in office.

The president averaged nearly 5.9 false or misleading claims a day in his first year in office. He hit nearly 16.5 a day in his second year. So far in 2019, he’s averaging nearly 22 claims a day.

As of the end of March 3, the 773rd day of his term in office, Trump accumulated 9,014 fishy claims, according to The Fact Checker’s database that analyzes, categorizes and tracks every suspect statement uttered by the president.

Trump’s performance at CPAC is emblematic of his version of the truth during his presidency — a potent mix of exaggerated numbers, unwarranted boasting and outright falsehoods. His speech helped push March 3 to his fourth-biggest day for false or misleading claims, totaling 104.

The speech included his greatest hits: 131 times he has falsely said he passed the biggest tax cut in history, 126 times he has falsely said his border wall is already being built and 116 times he has asserted that the U.S. economy today is the best in history. All three of those claims are on The Fact Checker’s list of Bottomless Pinocchios, as well as other claims Trump made during his CPAC speech.

Fishing and Eating Like Ancient Hawaiians

Negative Equality is No Virtue

After UW-Whitewater’s chancellor, Beverly Kopper, resigned in December, faculty member JoEllen Burkholder objected that Kopper’s resignation would amount to a double standard:

Some faculty members, such as women’s and gender studies professor JoEllen Burkholder, questioned the timing of Kopper’s resignation coming before the report’s release. Burkholder said she sees Kopper’s one-sentence resignation letter submitted to the UW System Board of Regents as an indication that she was likely pressured to resign, saying a “double standard” would exist if she was forced out based solely on someone else’s misbehavior.

There was an ample basis to dismiss Kopper – or ask her to resign – based on her own behavior: she concealed from the campus two separate investigations into her publicly-appointed spouse’s conduct. (The information only became public following a public-records request and a pending newspaper story. A third investigation has now been completed but not yet released.)

Burkholder’s double-standard argument, however, implies – indeed rests upon – the claim that if a male chancellor would not have been asked to resign, then Kopper should not have been asked to resign.

This argument rests on a claim of negative equality: that if one does not address misconduct in one instance, it should not be addressed in other instances (keeping negative experiences equal between genders, races, ages, etc.).

The opposite is how one typically – and rightly – thinks about equality: the extension of positive conditions to more people (of all genders, races, and ages).

One was reminded of Burkholder’s argument after reading Elizabeth Bruenig’s article addressing questions about Sen. Amy Klobuchar’s temperament:

There’s a reflexive kind of defensiveness that comes from the realization that women are judged more harshly than men for the same behavior. It tells us that fairness matters — and it does. But there are positive and negative forms of fairness. Negative fairness is a kind of fairness that reduces everyone to an equally bad position. Arguments that we ought to discount coverage of Klobuchar’s maltreatment of her staffers on gender-egalitarian grounds, for instance, really hold that because we wrongly accept male abuse of workers, we also ought to accept female abuse of workers. But the reality is actually the reverse: We rightly don’t accept female abuse of workers, and we shouldn’t accept male abuse of workers, either. This line of criticism is both gender-egalitarian and aimed at increasing the overall common good by creating a moral expectation that all workers be treated with dignity. That’s positive fairness.

(I’ve no idea about Sen. Klobuchar’s temperament; it’s Bruenig’s remarks on negative equality or negative fairness that caught my attention.)

The justification for Kopper’s departure isn’t impaired by unfairly retaining other failed leaders. On the contrary, other leaders’ lingering presence only stands in greater contrast (and that contrast demands action for their removal).

A better campus, a better city, and a better society will not come through an equal acceptance of misconduct, but instead through an equal redress of misconduct wherever one finds it.