FREE WHITEWATER

Trane Presents an Energy-Savings Contract

WGTB logo PNG 112x89 Post 10 in a series.

Trane Presents an Energy-Savings Contract from John Adams on Vimeo.

Recap: On 11.5.13, city officials in Whitewater met privately with three construction or engineering vendors (Trane, Black & Veatch, Donohue) and at least one major waste-hauler to discuss importing waste from other cities into Whitewater for a digester energy project. On 12.3.13, Whitewater’s Wastewater Superintendent Reel and City Manager Clapper presented a brief slideshow about the project, and revealed the prior meeting. On 1.21.14, Trane and Black & Veatch presented to Whitewater’s Common Council on the project. On 2.4.14, the City of Whitewater, at the enthusiastic recommendation of Reel and Clapper, agreed to fund Trane’s ‘study’ on the feasibility of the project, in an amount up to $150,000.

(We’ve also skipped ahead in the story, to a presentation from Clapper and Reel from 3.16.15 at the Whitewater School Board, to see how they’ve crafted a sales presentation – one of several – to major institutions and groups in the city. Later, we’ll be able to examine how their more recent presentation claims match their prior statements, prior engineering statements, and independent analyses of digester projects like this.)

(Every question in this series has a unique number, assigned chronologically based on when it was asked.  All the questions from When Green Turns Brown can be found in the Question Bin.  Today’s questions begin with No. 108.)

For today, this post looks at Trane’s presentation – from some of the same representatives who spoke to Council about the digester project – on a separate, supposed energy-savings project for Whitewater. It’s useful as a look at Trane’s work, but just as much into the thinking and diligence of Whitewater’s municipal administration.

108. Whitewater selected Trane for this energy-efficiency project (here, making several Whitewater municipal buildings supposedly more energy-efficient, for example). Who else applied? Why Trane? (Ten years earlier Whitewater used Honeywell.)

109. Like Trane’s work on the digester, this energy-efficiency project would be under a single-vendor performance-contract (rather than a separate designer and contractor approach sent to bid that would be common for most construction projects). Why choose this method over a traditional one?

110. Trane claims there would be $2,219,055 in savings to the city over fifteen years. How much have we, now in 2015, saved based on this estimate?

111. Obvious question: if we’ve not saved a fractional amount equal consistent with Trane’s calculations, then why is that? (It’s an obvious question, but the answer’s not been published anywhere, to my knowledge.)

112. The total project cost is about $1,900,000. Even after a ninety-day review from Trane, Trane’s final numbers are not available at this meeting. Why, then, present tonight? That is, why the urgency?

113. These are projects for the municipal building, library, armory, Cravath, Starin Park, and city garage. How critical are any of them?

114.  Both Trane and city officials contend that these projects are urgent because of the weather.  Are they really?

115.  A city leader contends that inadequate air conditioning for the city administration in the municipal building is an urgent matter.   Is it?  How many workers in Whitewater have no air conditioning at any time?  How many residents in Whitewater have no air conditioning at any time?

116.  At about 34:00 into the clip of the meeting, several city officials or Council members laugh at the idea of not have improved air conditioning at the municipal building.  Does it seem equally absurd to them that many ordinary residents live and work without air conditioning?

117.  Trane contends that the entire project could be executed in 2014.  Was it?

118.  City Manager Clapper does not state the amount in the city capital budget that could be used for the scope of project cost, but Rachel of Trane knows it from memory.  Why does the vendor know the municipal budget figure but the city’s own manager does not?

Original Common Council Discussion, 2.20.14
Agenda: http://www.whitewater-wi.gov/images/stories/agendas/common_council/2014/2-20-2014_Full_Packet_C.pdf
Minutes: Unpublished.
Video: https://vimeo.com/87518039

WHEN GREEN TURNS BROWN: Mondays @ 10 AM, here on FREE WHITEWATER.

Daily Bread for 6.1.15

Good morning, Whitewater.

Monday in town will be sunny with a high of sixty-six. Sunrise is 5:18 and sunset 8:26, for 15h 08m 15s of daytime. The moon is a waxing gibbous with 98.4% of its visible disk illuminated.

For Friday’s FW poll, on whether Golden State or Cleveland would win the NBA championship, most respondents (56%) picked Golden State.  We’ll know soon enough; the final begin Thursday.

On this day in 1779, a court martial (about charges before later treason) of Benedict Arnold begins (only to conclude months after beginning):

The court martial to consider the charges against Arnold began meeting on June 1, 1779, but was delayed until December 1779 by General Clinton’s capture of Stony Point, New York, throwing the army into a flurry of activity to react.[67] A number of members of the panel of judges were ill-disposed to Arnold over actions and disputes earlier in the war, yet Arnold was cleared of all but two minor charges on January 26, 1780.[68] Arnold worked over the next few months to publicize this fact; however, in early April, just one week after Washington congratulated Arnold on the March 19 birth of his son, Edward Shippen Arnold, Washington published a formal rebuke of Arnold’s behavior.[69]

The Commander-in-Chief would have been much happier in an occasion of bestowing commendations on an officer who had rendered such distinguished services to his country as Major General Arnold; but in the present case, a sense of duty and a regard to candor oblige him to declare that he considers his conduct [in the convicted actions] as imprudent and improper.

— Notice published by George Washington, April 6, 1780[70]

Puzzability begins a new weekly series entitled, Six Packs:

This Week’s Game — June 1-5
Six-Packs
We’ve got a splinter group of trivia every day this week. For each day, we’ll give you a category and a list of all the members of that category with six letters in their names—except one.
Example:
Current Supreme Court justices: Breyer, Thomas
Answer:
Scalia
What to Submit:
Submit the missing category member (as “Scalia” in the example) for your answer.
Monday, June 1
Signs of the zodiac: Cancer, Pisces, Taurus

 

Conservatives Against WEDC

Only a generation ago (not long, really), most conservatives would have rejected something like the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation’s ineffectual, wasteful attempts to manipulate the economy for the benefit of a few insiders’ friends.

Today, communities across our state are beset with any number of unctuous men hawking a kind of big-government conservatism, with false promise after false promise about community development or job-creation. It’s junk economics, to be sure, but for every oily salesman there’s an obliging, oily toad among the press happy to flack these shams.

Fortunately, there many who see though this, including conservatives who have not descended into hucksterism. (I’m a libertarian, not a conservative, yet I well know that there are varieties of conservatives, and conservatives who have not abandoned the truth of economic uplift through markets free of state interference.)

Consider the men and women of Wisconsin’s MacIver Institute as a positive example:

According to an article in the May issue of State Legislatures Magazine, states offer billions of dollars in subsidies with little to show for it.

“Today, every state offers at least some sort of tax incentive for businesses,” according to the article by Jackson Brainerd, a research analyst for the National Council of State Legislatures. “Yet, despite lawmakers’ enthusiasm for corporation-specific incentives, many economists, experts and other observers, from the left to the right, doubt they are an efficient use of public money.”

Groups including the conservative Madison-based MacIver Institute question whether states should even be in the business of subsidizing business.

“We believe government does not have a role in this arena,” said Brett Healy, executive director of MacIver, which promotes a free-market approach. “Any time the government gets involved in this type of corporate welfare, picking winners and losers, all sorts of problems crop up.

“If we take a step back and be honest with ourselves, this is not a critical or core mission of state government,” Healy said.

Well-said.

Via What should Wisconsin do to boost business? @ State Journal.

 

Daily Bread for 5.31.15

Good morning, Whitewater.

Sunday in town will be sunny and mild, with a high of sixty-three. Sunrise is 5:19 and sunset 8:26, for 15h 06m 59s of daytime. The moon is a waxing gibbous with 94.9% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1859, the clock on Elizabeth Tower (the tower named as such in 2012) goes into operation:

The name Big Ben is often used to describe the tower, the clock and the bell but the name was first given to the Great Bell.

The Elizabeth Tower, which stands at the north end of the Houses of Parliament, was completed in 1859 and the Great Clock started on 31 May, with the Great Bell’s strikes heard for the first time on 11 July and the quarter bells first chimed on 7 September….

Until installation in 1859, the clock was kept at Dent’s factory. Denison made many refinements including inventing the ‘Double Three-legged Gravity Escapement’. This was a revolutionary mechanism, ensuring the clock’s accuracy by making sure its pendulum was unaffected by external factors, such as wind pressure on the clock’s hands.

Denison’s invention has since been used in clocks all over the world. It is also known as the ‘Grimthorpe Escapement’ as Denison was made Baron Grimthorpe in 1886.

The clock was installed in the Clock Tower in April 1859. At first, it wouldn’t work as the cast-iron minute hands were too heavy. Once they were replaced by lighter copper hands, it successfully began keeping time on 31 May 1859. It was not long before the chimes of the Great Bell, also known as Big Ben, joined in.

On this day in 1899, the Gideons are founded in Beaver Dam:

On this night two salesmen, John H. Nicholson and Samuel E. Hill, crossed paths a second time, in Beaver Dam. The pair had first met eight months before in the Central Hotel in Boscobel and discussed the need for some way to provide Christian support to traveling businessmen. During this second meeting in Beaver Dam the two decided to “get right at it. Start the ball rolling and follow it up.” They invited their professional contacts to an organizational meeting to be held in Janesville on July 1, 1899, at which the organization was formally named and chartered. By 1948, The Gideons had distributed over 15 million bibles world-wide. View more information about the Beginning of The Gideons International.

Daily Bread for 5.30.15

Good morning, Whitewater.

We’ll have a rainy day in town with a high of sixty-six.  Sunrise is 5:19 and sunset 8:25, for 15h 05m 39s of daytime.  The moon is a waxing gibbous with 89.9% of its visible disk illuminated.

MIT has been designing robots, including a robot called the cheetah, for its running ability.  (See, from 2014 @ FW, The Rise of the Robo-Cheetahs.)  Those robots have been improved, and can now jump:

It will be an advantage, I think, to have liked cats when these robo-cheetahs come to dominate the planet. I promise to put in a good word for the rest of you.

On this day in 1971, Mariner 9 leaves for Mars:

Mariner 9 (Mariner Mars ’71 / Mariner-I) was an unmanned NASA space probe that contributed greatly to the exploration of Mars and was part of the Mariner program. Mariner 9 was launched toward Mars on May 30, 1971[1][2] from Cape Canaveral Air Force Station and reached the planet on November 14 of the same year,[1][2] becoming the first spacecraft to orbit another planet[3] — only narrowly beating the Soviets’ Mars 2 and Mars 3, which both arrived within a month. After months of dust storms it managed to send back clear pictures of the surface.

Mariner 9 returned 7329 images over the course of its mission, which concluded in October 1972.

Daily Bread for 5.29.15

Good morning, Whitewater.

Friday will be cloudy, with a probability of thunderstorms, and a high of eighty. Sunrise is 5:20 and sunset 8:24, for 15h 04m 18s of daytime. The moon is a waxing gibbous with 82.8% of its visible disk illuminated.

On this day in 1953, Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay reach the summit:

A series of advanced camps were created, slowly reaching higher up the mountain.[15] Camp II at 19,400 feet was established by Hillary, Band and Lowe on 15 April, Camp III at the head of the Icefall at 20,200 feet on 22 April, and Camp IV by Hunt, Bourdillon and Evans on 1 May.[14]These three made a preliminary reconnaissance of the Lhotse Face on 2 May, and Camp V at 22,000 feet was established on 3 May.[14] On 4 May, Bourdillon and Evans, supported by Ward and Wylie, reached Camp VI at 23,000 feet on the Lhotse Face, and just under a fortnight later on 17 May, Wilfrid Noyce and Lowe established Camp VII at 24,000 feet.[14] By 21 May, Noyce and the Sherpa Annullu (the younger brother of Da Tenzing) had reached the South Col, just under 26,000 feet. The first of two climbing pairs previously selected by Hunt, Tom Bourdillon and Charles Evans, set out for the summit on 26 May using closed-circuit oxygen and successfully achieved the first ascent of the 8,750 m (28,700 ft) South Summit, coming within 100 m (300 ft) of the final summit. They were forced to turn back after becoming exhausted, defeated by oxygen equipment problems and lack of time.[16] On 27 May, the expedition made its second and final assault on the summit with the second climbing pair, the New Zealander Edmund Hillary and Sherpa Tenzing Norgay from Nepal. Norgay had previously ascended to a record high point on Everest as a member of the Swiss expedition of 1952. They reached the summit at 11:30 am on 29 May 1953, climbing the South Col route. Before descending, they stopped at the summit long enough to take photographs and to bury some sweets and a small cross in the snow.[15]

On this day in 1848, Wisconsin enters the Union:

On this date Wisconsin became the 30th state to enter the Union with an area of 56,154 square miles, comprising 1/56 of the United States at the time. Its nickname, the “Badger State,” was not in reference to the fierce animal but miners who spent their winters in the state, living in dugouts and burrowing much like a badger. [Source: “B” Book I, Beer Bottles, Brawls, Boards, Brothels, Bibles, Battles & Brownstone by Tony Woiak, pg. 37]

Here’s the final game in this week’s Cheese Filling series from Puzzability:

This Week’s Game — May 25-29
Cheese Filling
We’ve got string cheese on the menu all week. For each day, we’ll give you three clues, each of which leads to a word. The answers to two of those clues, when placed together in the right order, have the name of a cheese spanning the gap between the answers. When the cheese’s name is removed, the remaining letters, in order, spell the answer to the day’s remaining clue. The clues are presented in random order.
Example:
Affleck’s Good Will Hunting costar; river of South America; astound
Answer:
AMAZEDAMON (Damon, Amazon, amaze; the cheese is Edam)
What to Submit:
Submit just the full string of letters, with the cheese in the middle (as “AMAZEDAMON” in the example), for your answer.
Friday, May 29
Discord; partner of sine and cosine; rigorous, as rules

Pip the Pug

Pip the Pug is not merely one of the smallest dogs in Britain, but likely in all the world:

Meet Pip, the tiny pug who at just four inches high is one of the smallest dogs in the UK.

At four months old, she weighs only 1lbs 4 ounces – about the same as a bag of sugar.

The miniature pet is so small it can fit into a gravy boat and on long walks will travel around in her owner’s handbag….

Joanne [Astley], 54, decided to start breeding pugs last year, and was delighted when two-year-old Ruby gave birth to a litter of four in January.

But her delight soon turned to shock when she realised that one of the puppies was half the size of the others.

Joanne said: ‘I couldn’t believe it – she was just so tiny.

‘We took her to the vet, but they said that she was fine, apart from a cleft lip, and is just small.

‘We love our little Pip so much – I thought she was going to grow up quickly, but she’s stayed so little.

‘Pip’s about half the size of her sister.’

Mother-of-four Joanne and gas engineer partner Steve Madelin, 56, decided to keep tiny Pip and one of her sisters, Poppy.

Pip, a purebred pug, is almost exactly half the size a four-month-old pug pup should be.

more >>

Restaurant Review: Karina’s Mexican Restaurant (Revisited)

Karina’s Mexican Restaurant recently opened on the west side of Whitewater.  I reviewed the establishment at its then-downtown location about two years ago. 

Karina’s is now located immediately to the west of Subway, in the same building, and east of Rocky Rococo’s.  I’m not interested in reviewing those chains, but having returned to Karina’s I’d suggest that either would likely be preferable to Karina’s.

Realtors say that everything depends on location, location, location.  Perhaps that’s true, but then when saying so they’re talking about real property, not food.

Location has not improved an overly-full menu (with too many items for this establishment), unattractively presented on the plate, with only sporadically attentive service. 

The menu is too thick, and the salsa to thin, so to speak. 

I had hoped for a better experience than my prior visits, but time hasn’t changed the fundamentals in need of changing.  

My prior remarks remain pertinent to describe Karina’s. 

LOCATION: 1170 W Main St, Whitewater, WI 53190 (262) 472-9492. See, Google Map directions linked at the beginning of this review.

PRICES: Main dish, drink, and complimentary chips & too-thin salsa about $10.

RESERVATIONS: Unnecessary.

DRINKS & WINE: Mexican beer, margaritas.

SERVICE: Sporadically attentive.

VISITS: One (as a dinner revisit).

RATING: Fair.
GoldStarGoldStar

RATING SCALE: From one to four stars, representing the full experience of food, atmosphere, service, and pricing.

INDEPENDENCE: This review is delivered without financial or other connection to the establishment or its owner. The dining experience was that of an ordinary patron, without notice to the staff or requests for special consideration.

Daily Bread for 5.28.15

Good morning, Whitewater.

Thursday in town will be mostly sunny with a high of eighty-three. Sunrise is 5:20 and sunset 8:23, for 15h 02m 52s of daytime. The moon is a waxing gibbous with 74.9% of its visible disk illuminated.

Today, Thursday morning, Downtown Whitewater’s Board meets at 8 AM. I am often asked about Downtown Whitewater, and my thoughts on their present work.  Having watched closely, and heard much, I’ve no immediate answer to offer.  The market – that collection of voluntary transactions among countless people each day – will decide the shape and future of Whitewater’s downtown.  I’m not sure in which direction some of these forces will lead in our near-future.  It’s enough for now to wait and see.

On this day in 1754, George Washington experiences his first combat, in the French and Indian War. He’s victorious, but the engagement is undisciplined, and has been controversial ever since. One is reminded that even a great man, later able to defeat the greatest empire on earth, and later still lead his own new republic ably for eight years, had hesitant and awkward moments:

George Washington, a young lieutenant colonel in the British Army and future president of the United States, leads an attack on French forces at Jumonville Glen on this day in 1754. The battle is later credited with being the opening salvo in the French and Indian War (1754 to 1763).

In the biography His Excellency: George Washington, historian Joseph Ellis recounts Washington’s first combat experience. Washington and 40 colonial troops had been encamped near the French garrison at Fort Duquesne when he received an urgent message to rescue Indian allies in the area who were threatened by French forces. In his official report of the encounter, Washington described how his troops, aided by warriors under the Indian leader Tanacharison, surrounded a detachment of 32 French soldiers near the fort on May 28 and, within 15 minutes, killed 10 of them, including the garrison’s commander, wounded one and took another 21 prisoner.

Controversy surrounded the attack both at the time and after the war. Historical accounts indicate that the French commander, Joseph Coulon De Jumonville had actually tried to surrender but was slain by Tanacharison. Tanacharison’s rash act incited the other warriors to kill and scalp nine other French soldiers before Washington could intervene. Ellis describes Washington as shocked and hapless and writes that he later tried to downplay the incident to his commanding officer. The French vilified Washington as the epitome of dishonor. The Jumonville Glen massacre remains a highly debated subject among scholars. In the aftermath of the encounter, Washington resigned his British army commission and returned to his family’s plantation. In 1775, he returned to military service to lead the Continental Army in the American Revolutionary War.

Here’s the Thursday game in Puzzability‘s Cheese Filling series:

This Week’s Game — May 25-29
Cheese Filling
We’ve got string cheese on the menu all week. For each day, we’ll give you three clues, each of which leads to a word. The answers to two of those clues, when placed together in the right order, have the name of a cheese spanning the gap between the answers. When the cheese’s name is removed, the remaining letters, in order, spell the answer to the day’s remaining clue. The clues are presented in random order.
Example:
Affleck’s Good Will Hunting costar; river of South America; astound
Answer:
AMAZEDAMON (Damon, Amazon, amaze; the cheese is Edam)
What to Submit:
Submit just the full string of letters, with the cheese in the middle (as “AMAZEDAMON” in the example), for your answer.
Thursday, May 28
Bugler’s bedtime tune; fruit used to make brandy and Sacher torte; smartphone programs