FREE WHITEWATER

Daily Bread for 3.31.19

Good morning.

Sunday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of forty-one.  Sunrise is 6:37 AM and sunset 7:20 PM, for 12h 42m 56s of daytime.  The moon is a waning crescent with 20.5% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1889, the Eiffel Tower opens:

The main structural work was completed at the end of March 1889 and, on 31 March, Eiffel celebrated by leading a group of government officials, accompanied by representatives of the press, to the top of the tower.[12] Because the lifts were not yet in operation, the ascent was made by foot, and took over an hour, with Eiffel stopping frequently to explain various features. Most of the party chose to stop at the lower levels, but a few, including the structural engineer, Émile Nouguier, the head of construction, Jean Compagnon, the President of the City Council, and reporters from Le Figaro and Le Monde Illustré, completed the ascent. At 2:35 pm, Eiffel hoisted a large Tricolour to the accompaniment of a 25-gun salute fired at the first level.[24]

Recommended for reading in full:

  Craig Gilbert writes Tuesday’s court race is the biggest Wisconsin election of the year. What will it tell us about the mood of the voters?:

Have conservatives lost the upper hand in Supreme Court races?

The more conservative candidate has won 10 of 14 Supreme Court elections in Wisconsin dating back to 2000. But the more liberal candidate has won two of the past three contested races (2015 and 2018). A Neubauer victory would make it three of four.

Can Hagedorn overcome the ever-growing electoral clout of liberal Dane County?

Dane County, home to Madison, is easily the fastest-growing part of Wisconsin and its sky-high level of political engagement can give it even more electoral impact in a low-turnout April race than in a higher-turnout November race.

A little history makes the point. Two decades ago, Dane County voted for the more conservative Supreme Court candidate, Diane Sykes, against Louis Butler in 2000. It has voted for the more liberal candidate ever since, by larger and larger margins.

Last year, it supported winning court candidate Rebecca Dallet by 62 percentage points. It also accounted for 13.4% of the votes cast statewide. That was its highest share ever in a court race and a higher share of the statewide vote than any other county, including the much larger Milwaukee (which accounted for 13.1% of the statewide vote) and the biggest Republican County, Waukesha (8.9% of the statewide vote).

  Anna Nemtsova writes Putin’s Crackdown on Dissent Is Working (“A new law criminalizing “disrespect” for Russian society and institutions might mark the end of the country’s few remaining legal forms of protests”):

The new law on disrespecting state symbols, in particular, intends to choke off freedom of speech, according to Rachel Denber, the Europe and Central Asia deputy director for Human Rights Watch. “Why else is it necessary, other than to ban people who are critical of the government, to demonize criticism and dissent?” she asked me.

  Four Stories About Inventors and Their Inventions:

Local Elections 2019: Municipal Court (Part 4 of 4)

Whitewater has a municipal court, and since a municipal court then a municipal judge presiding over that court. In the course of the campaign between Chad Buehler and Patrick Taylor, the candidates have discussed questions of experience, background, and perspective.  They’ve both offered outlines of how they would serve, but they both face this same challenge to those aspirations: the role of the court has slowly shrunk into a fee-processing source of municipal revenue.  Indeed, one could guess many residents haven’t thought much about Whitewater’s municipal court in many years.

That’s a shame, truly.  Libertarians are not in the habit of encouraging government to be bigger than necessary, but nor are we in the habit of encouraging less from government where it does have a necessary role.

When this election is over, one of these two candidates will have the task of making this local court more than what it has been.  To do this, someone will have to make campaign aspirations into daily practice.

That’s no easy task in this beautiful, but sometimes troubled, city.

Previously:

Local Elections 2019: The Limits of Local (Part 1 of 4), Local Elections 2019: School Board (Part 2 of 4), and Local Elections 2019: City Council (Part 3 of 4).

Daily Bread for 3.30.19

Good morning.

Saturday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of fifty-four.  Sunrise is 6:39 AM and sunset 7:19 PM, for 12h 40m 02s of daytime.  The moon is a waning crescent with 27.8% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1865, the Wisconsinites fight at the Battle at Gravelly Run, Virginia:

The Battle at Gravelly Run erupted east of Petersburg, Virginia. The 6th, 7th and 36th Wisconsin Infantry regiments participated in this battle, which was one of a series of engagements that ultimately drove Confederate forces out of Petersburg. Wisconsin’s Iron Brigade regiments fought at Gravelly Run, and when ordered to fall back before the enemy, they were the last to leave the field.

Recommended for reading in full:

Mariana Zuñiga, Anthony Faiola, and Anton Troianovski report As Maduro confronts a crisis, Russia’s footprint in Venezuela grows:

 After two Russian military planes landed near Caracas this month, the Trump administration issued stark warnings over President Nicolás Maduro’s ties to the Kremlin. But a vessel that arrived in the waters off Venezuela’s Caribbean coast a day earlier offered a more telling sign of a deepening relationship that is so alarming to Washington.

Venezuela has the world’s largest known oil reserves, with transport and sales of its thick, sludgy crude long dependent on chemical thinners purchased from the United States. After Washington barred U.S. companies from selling them to Venezuela in January — and warned foreign companies to follow suit — Maduro faced a dire predicament: How would he stave off the industry’s total collapse?

Like manna from Moscow, an answer arrived in the form of a red-and-black tanker, the Serengeti, that loaded a cargo of thinners off the coast of Malta before arriving in Venezuela on March 22. The company that chartered the vessel: Russia’s state-run oil giant Rosneft.

Alina Polyakova writes Want to know what’s next in Russian election interference? Pay attention to Ukraine’s elections:

With Russia’s continued occupation of Crimea and war in the Donbas, Ukraine also remains a key arena of contestation between Russia and the West. Ukraine is a large European country with a population of 45 million people. It is rich in natural resources and human capital, and its success or failure in achieving long-lasting democratic and economic reforms can tip the balance in great power contestation. The Kremlin seeks to prevent Ukraine from moving toward the West by keeping it in a permanent “grey zone.” To achieve that goal, Russia continues to destabilize Ukraine through conventional and nonconventional military means while seeking to undermine Ukraine’s democratic and economic reform process. Deterring an increasingly aggressive Russia must start in Ukraine.

….

There have been at least 15 known Russian-attributed cyberattacks on Ukraine since 2014. A December 2015 cyberattack caused a blackout affecting over 230,000 Ukrainians. The malware used in that attack has been detected in electric utilities in the United States.

  Why Garfield phones have been washing up on French beaches for decades:

Local Elections 2019: City Council (Part 3 of 4)

In 1926, Hugo Gernsback began publishing Amazing Stories, an American science fiction magazine of fantastic, but entertaining, tales.  The magazine was benign: even if the stories described impossible or improbable events, they caused no practical harm.

One cannot say the same about lingering fantasies of fiscal and economic policy in Whitewater, Wisconsin: they produce real waste and real stagnation.

Consider the remarks of an incumbent city council member, who contends that the city could have an ongoing full-service grocery if only government  threw money at a developer:

The major expense of opening a grocery store is the building and land. The CDA is currently working with several developers that would receive incentives from the city and federal government to lower the lease cost of a grocery store. The lower lease cost would tip the decision in favor of locating in Whitewater.

This is a gross over-simplification of an out of-town grocer’s prospects, but it fits perfectly with the simple-minded approach of Whitewater’s Community Development Authority.  That sad bunch has thrown hundreds of thousands – millions over the years – of public money on out-of-town businesses that have skipped town without paying their obligations.

Indeed, they’ve made so many bad picks with public money that confidence in their judgment is like hoping that somehow, someday, the Titanic‘s designer might build a ship that stays afloat.  Best to move on, frankly.

More significantly: the most important element of a grocery’s success is the ongoing relationship it has with consumers in the local community —  its ability to gain and keep repeat business.  It’s most certainly not covering the startup costs that will assure success — success requires an ability to win back to Whitewater customers who now shop elsewhere.  Two prior full-service groceries in Whitewater learned this lesson, and someone who’s lived in Whitewater for, let’s say, twenty-three years should have a better appreciation of how our consumer environment has fared.

If the ongoing conduct of a business were not decisive, companies would not conduct market surveys, advertising, curated product offerings, product sales, employee coaching, community events, etc.

Claiming business insight while showing no candor on this point suggests either a lack of understanding or a desire to pander.

The self-professed development gurus in this city have done nothing to improve key metrics of individual and household prosperity, but they’ve achieved volumes of Amazing Stories all their own.

Previously:

Local Elections 2019: The Limits of Local (Part 1 of 4) and Local Elections 2019: School Board (Part 2 of 4).

Daily Bread for 3.29.19

Good morning.

Friday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of fifty-four.  Sunrise is 6:40 AM and sunset 7:17 PM, for 12h 37m 08s of daytime.  The moon is a waning crescent with 37.7% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1865, the Appomattox Campaign begins in Virginia:

When it became clear that the Confederate capital at Richmond, Virginia, was about to fall, Confederate leaders and troops began moving west toward the town of Appomattox Court House. Union troops, including several Wisconsin regiments, followed close on their heels in a series of battles fought March 29 – April 9, 1865, that became known as the Appomattox Campaign.

Recommended for reading in full:

Domenico Martanaro reports Poll: After Barr Letter, Overwhelming Majority Wants Full Mueller Report Released:

Days after Attorney General William Barr released his four-page summary of special counsel Robert Mueller’s Russia investigation report, overwhelming majorities of Americans want the full report made public and believe Barr and Mueller should testify before Congress, according to a new NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll.

Only about a third of Americans believe, from what they’ve seen or heard about the Mueller investigation so far, that President Trump is clear of any wrongdoing.

Ronald Brownstein writes Trump’s Opponents Have One Assignment Now:

Trump has demonstrated that there is a substantial audience in the evolving Republican electoral coalition for a message that combines open appeals to white racial resentments and unrelenting attacks on “elites” with an undiluted commitment to the traditional goals of economic and social conservatives—from cutting taxes and eliminating environmental regulations, to opposing abortion and installing conservative justices on the Supreme Court. The appeal of that formula for significant elements of the GOP base would not disappear even if Trump were forced from office by one of the many investigations still swirling around him. Perhaps the only way other Republicans might be discouraged from following Trump’s volatile path is if voters show them that it’s an electoral dead end by repudiating it in 2020.

….

The GOP’s reliance on the white voters most uneasy about a changing America ensures that there will always be a substantial constituency inside the party for the backward-looking, racially divisive populism that Trump has synthesized. But a sliver of Republicans still share the perspective of the party’s famous “autopsy” report after Barack Obama’s reelection; that analysis concluded that the GOP must seek to engage with America’s growing minority population rather than try to mobilize more white support by portraying that diversity as a threat, as Trump has done. The sheer weight of demographic change could strengthen the “autopsy” position over time, especially if, through the coming years, it becomes clear that Trump’s approach has alienated too many other voters to win elections, as was the case in 2018.

(Fundamentally, this was always the primary assignment of Trump’s opposition: to consign him and his movement to the political outer darkness.)

  Kangaroo rats use lighting-fast ‘ninja-style’ kicks to avoid predators, researchers say:

Local Elections 2019: School Board (Part 2 of 4)

The Whitewater area – the city proper and smaller townships nearby – are jointly part of a unified public school district. These last years have been difficult for Wisconsin educational funding, for the rural economies in this part of the state, and surely for Whitewater in both matters.

The district has recently completed both a construction referendum and a separate operational referendum, has had some admirable academic successes, but also has general academic challenges all districts in the area face.

Over time, this district administration (located at ‘Central Office’ and often referred to as such) has shown less concern for ordinary transparency, and has instead communicated most zealously in bursts (when, for example, the district was marketing its recent referendums).

More significant still, much work of the district comes from its so-called district leadership team (school principals and a few administrators); projects from these meetings are reachable under Wisconsin’s Public Records Law but not the state’s Open Meetings Law.  Significant decisions in these meetings are often advanced with limited board oversight and even less community review beforehand.

Under these conditions, two challengers (Amy Hagen-Curtis and Jennifer Kienbaum) and one incumbent (Jim Stewart) are seeking seats on the board.  (There are two seats available.)

Stewart has been in one office or another in Whitewater for decades, and offers as his comparative advantage that he has been in one office or another in Whitewater for decades.

Here is the policy challenge to his candidacy: with the school district’s referendums now successfully adopted, the supposed advantages his incumbency offers are wildly overblown. The two challengers in this race – Hagen-Curtis and Kienbaum – are easily as able to oversee the district’s ongoing financial affairs.  There is no overwhelming new financial challenge that requires decades of experience, even setting aside the question of whether Stewart has exercised effective oversight (rather than ceaseless boosterism of ineffectual municipal-government projects).

There are, however, new challenges that this district faces – of transparency, of employee retention, of mental health, of family stresses of rural parents, and of special needs students – that sentimental but irrelevant history lessons of many years ago cannot solve.

These new challenges – often severe in rural America – are ones that require both a more contemporary outlook and a high degree of energy and inquisitiveness.

How Whitewater will decide in this election one can’t be sure.  That the challengers in this race are as capable of financial oversight, and would be more energetic in addressing current afflictions besetting our schools, is certain.

It would be a mistake – an educational loss for the community – not to take the opportunity that challengers Amy Hagen-Curtis and Jennifer Kienbaum offer.

Previously:

Local Elections 2019: The Limits of Local (Part 1 of 4).

Daily Bread for 3.28.19

Good morning.

Thursday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of fifty-nine.  Sunrise is 6:42 AM and sunset 7:16 PM, for 12h 34m 14s of daytime.  The moon is a waning crescent with 47.1% of its visible disk illuminated.

Whitewater’s Community Development Authority meets at 5:30 PM.

On this day in 1979, there was a partial meltdown of the Three Mile Island nuclear reactor in Pennsylvania.

Recommended for reading in full:

Dan Alexander reports Trump Has Now Shifted $1.3 Million Of Campaign-Donor Money Into His Business:

Donald Trump has charged his own reelection campaign $1.3 million for rent, food, lodging and other expenses since taking office, according to a Forbes analysis of the latest campaign filings. And although outsiders have contributed more than $50 million to the campaign, the billionaire president hasn’t handed over any of his own cash. The net effect: $1.3 million of donor money has turned into $1.3 million of Trump money.

In December, Forbes reported on the first $1.1 million that President Trump moved from his campaign into his business. Since then, his campaign filed additional documentation showing that it spent another $180,000 at Trump-owned properties in the final three months of 2018.

None of this seemed likely when Donald Trump first got into politics. “I don’t need anybody’s money,” he announced on the day he launched his 2016 campaign, standing inside the marble atrium at Trump Tower. “I’m using my own money. I’m not using the lobbyists. I’m not using donors. I don’t care. I’m really rich.”

Drew Harwell and Tony Romm report ICE is tapping into a huge license-plate database, ACLU says, raising new privacy concerns about surveillance:

Immigration agents have been tapping into a vast, privately maintained database of license plate numbers gleaned from vehicles across the United States to track down people who may be in the country illegally, according to documents obtained by the American Civil Liberties Union and released Wednesday.

The database contains billions of records on vehicle locations captured from red-light and speed-limit cameras as well as from parking lots and toll roads that use the nearly ubiquitous and inexpensive scanners to monitor vehicle comings and goings.

Local police forces have long used those scanners to track criminal suspects and enforce traffic laws across the United States. But the records the ACLU obtained from the Department of Homeland Security through a Freedom of Information Act request shed new light on a little-noticed and expanding network of surveillance that has developed over the years and for which there appear to be few legal limitations.

The revelation drew sharp criticism from Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, who said the mere notion of “a massive, for-profit location-tracking database is about the worst idea I have ever heard of when it comes to Americans’ privacy and security.”

“There needs to be strong rules around how sensitive data like this is stored and controlled – location data of millions of Americans is a ripe target for predators, domestic abusers, and foreign spies,” he said in a statement.

  Twilight Zone: The True Story:

Local Elections 2019: The Limits of Local (Part 1 of 4)

Whitewater, like other cities in Wisconsin, will hold local elections on Tuesday, April 2nd. Even in difficult times, this state and this country has carried on, and properly so, with local elections.

In Whitewater, residents of the city will vote for council members, school board members, and for the city’s next municipal judge. Those races matter, to the city and (surely) to the candidates contesting for them.

For today, a reminder – although one should not be needed – about the context of these local elections. Some Whitewater residents may have heard that discussion of local races should be confined to state or regional matters, or that the absence of local news increases partisanship.

Nothing could be worse for a people – and in a diverse city most of all – than to set aside from discussion the extraordinary national conflict that grips America. In matters of economic policy, immigration, and foreign affairs there are disputes that should not – and morally cannot – be ignored.  Each of the issues in this national conflict has a local impact.  America has millions of partisans in opposition and resistance; she would benefit from still more.

Perhaps someone living in Italy in 1925 might wish to talk only of local matters, but a man or woman so inclined would do so only by slighting threats that reached even the most remote Italian cities.

This truth, however, does not prevent any local consideration.

Over these next few days, I’ll offer a few remarks on the elections in this small city, contest by contest.

Daily Bread for 3.27.19

Good morning.

Wednesday in Whitewater will be partly sunny with a high of fifty-nine.  Sunrise is 6:44 AM and sunset 7:15 PM, for 12h 31m 20s of daytime.  The moon is a waning gibbous with 56.7% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1939, the University of Oregon defeats Ohio State University 46–33 on this day in 1939 to win the first-ever NCAA men’s basketball tournament.

 

Recommended for reading in full:

Paul Farhi reports Rachel Maddow, the left’s powerhouse on cable, won’t let the Mueller probe go:

A day after Attorney General William P. Barr said special prosecutor Robert S. Mueller III hadn’t found collusion between President Trump’s campaign and Russian agents, Maddow — prime-time TV’s primary and most tenacious proponent of the conspiracy angle — still was not buying it.

Instead, Maddow moved on to two related questions: Did Trump obstruct justice? And did Barr let him get away with it?

“Whatever information [Barr] just received from Robert Mueller about the president’s behavior as it pertains to potential criminal obstruction of justice, Barr could have just passed that information on to [Congress] for them to decide what to do with it,” Maddow said on her MSNBC program Monday night. “But instead, somewhat inexplicably, he decided to take it upon himself to declare definitively, ‘Yeah, you know, I looked at all that stuff, and I can tell you there is no crime there, it’s fine.’?”

She added: “Where did this come from? I mean, on what grounds are you saying that you have concluded there is no crime here?”

Maddow’s monologue suggests that she is unmoved by the many attacks on her for promoting a Russia conspiracy that, at least according to the attorney general, seems to have run aground. Her nightly deconstructions of the case against Trump have made her the signal figure of the anti-Trump left and have abetted her rise to the most popular figure in cable news.

….

As a parallel, she noted that Leon Jaworski, the special prosecutor in the Watergate investigation of President Richard Nixon, turned over his report to Congress in 1974, including damning grand-jury testimony against Nixon, without drawing conclusions about the president’s potential criminality.

She demanded the release of Mueller’s full report and underlying evidence, an idea the House endorsed unanimously earlier this month. She also raised 15 questions about Barr’s conduct, including the last, “Will Trump recognize Russia attacked our election?”

In all, it strongly suggested Maddow is not finished with Trump and the continuing investigations into his presidency.

(Good for her – there’s no reason to yield in the absence of a full and complete disclosure of the reasoned basis of Mueller’s report.)

  Spinning Water Droplets That Seemingly Defy Physics:

The Myth of a ‘Backfire Effect’ to Fact Checking

When someone debunks a claim or article through fact-checking,  does doing so generally produce a backfire effect where others commit even more strongly to the debunked notion?

No, not generally.

Laura Hazard Owen writes The “backfire effect” is mostly a myth, a broad look at the research suggests:

The growing stream of reporting on and data about fake news, misinformation, partisan content, and news literacy is hard to keep up with. This weekly roundup offers the highlights of what you might have missed.

“The backfire effect is in fact rare, not the norm.” Does fact-checking really make things worse? The U.K.’s independent fact-checking organization Full Fact looked at research into the so-called “backfire effect,” the idea (popular in the media) that “when a claim aligns with someone’s ideological beliefs, telling them that it’s wrong will actually make them believe it even more strongly.”

Full Fact research manager Amy Sippett reviewed seven studies that have explored the backfire effect and found that “cases where backfire effects were found tended to be particularly contentious topics, or where the factual claim being asked about was ambiguous.” The studies where a backfire effect was not found also tended to be larger than the studies where it was found. Full Fact cautions that most of the research on the backfire effect has been done in the U.S., and “we still need more evidence to understand how fact-checking content can be most effective.”

See Does the “backfire effect” exist—and does it matter for factcheckers?

A few remarks:

1. Fundamentally, one commits to fact-checking because the truth matters intrinsically, not merely for consequential reasons.

2. Liars or others who are loose with the facts would surely hope that they can say anything with impunity; it’s heartening to see that research, generally, refutes that dark hope.

3. Particular claims – the situational maneuverings of boosters, babbitts, and public-relations men – will always matter less than the weight over evidence collected over time.  In the relationship between maneuver and attrition, attrition is the more decisive force, as the weight of evidence and time leaves only dust in its path.

4. One hears sometimes that it’s easy to identify a problem or error but hard to fix one.  In politics, this is a platitude only: politicians, bureaucrats, lobbyists, fixers, development gurus, and lapdog reporters often speak and write falsely without ever being called out for their errors.

If fact-checking were truly easy, then it would be more common, as there is so much good work of refutation yet to be done.

Daily Bread for 3.26.19

Good morning.

Tuesday in Whitewater will be sunny with a high of forty-nine.  Sunrise is 6:46 AM and sunset 7:14 PM, for 12h 28m 24s of daytime.  The moon is a waning gibbous with 66.6% of its visible disk illuminated.

 

On this day in 1881, civil war mascot Old Abe dies:

Old Abe, famous Civil War mascot, died from injuries sustained during a fire at the State Capitol. Old Abe was the mascot for Company C, an Eau Claire infantry unit that was part of the Wisconsin 8th Regiment. During the Capitol fire of 1881, smoke engulfed Old Abe’s cage. One of his feathers survived and is in the Wisconsin Historical Museum. [Source: Wisconsin Lore and Legends, pg. 51]

Recommended for reading in full:

Thomas Heath reports Trump blames Fed for sub-4 percent growth; economists blame Trump:

Economists cast doubt on President Trump’s assertion in an interview aired Friday that the economy would have grown at a faster pace in 2018 — even as high as 4 percent — had the Federal Reserve not raised interest rates last year.

“If we didn’t have somebody that would raise interest rates and do quantitative tightening, we would have been at over 4 instead of a 3.1,” Trump said in a sit-down with anchor Maria Bartiromo on Fox Business Network.

The comments come just days after the Federal Reserve signaled it would not be raising rates again this year. The president has been critical of Fed Chairman Jerome H. Powell for the central bank’s gradual raising of interest rates — it did so four times last year. The president was reportedly so frustrated with his appointee that he asked internal and external advisers late last year whether he could fire Powell.

Economists say a 4 percent growth rate is difficult to reach.

”Four is just too high,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the American Action Forum, referring to the gross domestic product. Even with the Fed’s four rate increases last year, “by any historic standard, monetary policy remains loose.”

….

Holtz-Eakin said Trump’s policies actually contributed to holding economic expansion in check.

“Most people believe that the combination of a government shutdown, trade tensions, things (Trump) is responsible for, caused the slowing economy in the second half of 2018. He can complain all he wants, but I am not sure the evidence is on his side.”

Phillip Swagel, an economics professor at the University of Maryland, said the U.S. economy would have grown faster had Trump had not initiated a trade war with China.

“I don’t know if it would have reached 4 percent, but it would have been stronger,” Swagel said.

  Economist Justin Wolfers writes of Stephen Moore, Trump’s latest nominee to the Federal Reserve:

Here’s my challenge to any informed voter of any partisan leaning: Call your favorite economist. Whether they’re left, right, libertarian or socialist, none of them will endorse Stephen Moore for the Fed. He’s manifestly unqualified.

  How Did the Tradition of Cutting the Nets in Basketball Start?:

What Never Trump Means

Those libertarians (as I am) and conservatives who declared themselves Never Trump (written on Twitter as #NeverTrump) are those who took that position when considering Trump’s career and his presidential campaign.  On the ample record of Trump’s business career and political campaign, we found him unfit: a bigot, a would-be authoritarian, and an avowed friend of hostile foreign powers.

Trumpism unchecked would establish a herrenvolk state in the place of a free and truly democratic society. 

In this way, those libertarians and conservatives joined many millions more who were, by party membership or ideology, already inclined to oppose the 2016 GOP nominee.  In joining these many others, Never Trump became one part of a much larger coalition.

The main focus of opposition should be Trump, His Inner Circle, Principal Surrogates, and Media Defenders, but closer at hand there are yet officials supportive of Trumpism Down to the Local Level.

As for Never Trump, it was before the election that Never Trump began, before the inauguration that it began, and before all that has happened since.

There are some Americans who came to oppose Trump after the election, after the inauguration, after the appointment of a special counsel, or some other moment.  Their opposition is welcome; a larger coalition is a stronger coalition.

And yet, and yet — Trump’s political unworthiness is his very essence, and developments after the election, after the inauguration, after an appointment or another moment, change nothing of that essential unworthiness.

Never means never.