Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 1.4.19
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Friday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of forty-one. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:34 PM, for 9h 09m 23s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 1.9% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1923, Milton College president A.E. Whitford bans dancing by students in off-campus, semi-public places such as confectionery stores.
Recommended for reading in full:
David Frum asks Why Is Trump Spouting Russian Propaganda? (“The president’s endorsement of the U.S.S.R.’s invasion of Afghanistan echoes a narrative promoted by Vladimir Putin”):
Let’s go to the replay:
The reason Russia was in Afghanistan was because terrorists were going into Russia. They were right to be there.
To appreciate the shock value of Trump’s words, it’s necessary to dust off some Cold War history. Those of us who grew up in the last phases of the Cold War used to know it all by heart, but I admit I had to do a little Googling to refresh my faded memories.
It’s amazing enough that any U.S. president would retrospectively endorse the Soviet invasion. What’s even more amazing is that he would do so using the very same falsehoods originally invoked by the Soviets themselves: “terrorists” and “bandit elements.”
….It has been an important ideological project of the Putin regime to rehabilitate and justify the Soviet invasion and occupation of Afghanistan. Putin does not care so much about Afghanistan, but he cares a lot about the image of the U.S.S.R. In 2005, Putin described the collapse of the Soviet Union as (depending on your preferred translation) “the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century” or “a major geopolitical disaster of the 20th century”—but clearly a thing very much to be regretted.
See also Vladimir Kara-Murza’s essay Defying history, Moscow moves to defend Soviet war in Afghanistan.
Fatima Tils reports RT Claims WADA ‘Failed’ to Collect Data from Moscow Lab. Actually, Russian Authorities Denied Access:
The report by Russia Today (RT) report came a day after the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) announced that Russia has missed the December 31, 2018 deadline for compliance with the World Anti-Doping Code. By that deadline, the Russian authorities were supposed to meet two conditions imposed by WADA’s Executive Committee back in September.
Also on January 2, 16 national anti-doping organizations issued a joint statement calling on WADA to suspend Russia immediately, stating: “Russia has failed to meet its obligations.”
RT’s January 2 report used language implying that it was the World Anti-Doping Agency’s own fault for not being able to access Moscow laboratory (LIMS) data, and that WADA president Craig Reedie had seemingly expressed disappointment toward his own organization.
….
WADA followed with a statement on January 2 leaving no space for doubt about who the organization blamed for the failure: “We are extremely disappointed that the Dec. 31 deadline imposed on Russia by WADA has not been adhered to by the Russian authorities.”
Assault Awareness & Prevention, Harassment, Misconduct, Politics, Presidential race 2020
Sanders Says He Was ‘A Little Bit Busy’
by JOHN ADAMS •
Sydney Ember and Katie Benner report Sexism Claims from Bernie Sanders’s 2016 Run: Paid Less, Treated Worse:
In February 2016, Giulianna Di Lauro, a Latino outreach strategist for Senator Bernie Sanders’s presidential operation, complained to her supervisor that she had been harassed by a campaign surrogate whom she drove to events ahead of the Democratic primary in Nevada.
She said the surrogate told her she had “beautiful curly hair” and asked if he could touch it, Ms. Di Lauro said in an interview. Thinking he would just touch a strand, she consented. But she said that he ran his hand through her hair in a “sexual way” and continued to grab, touch and “push my boundaries” for the rest of the day.
“I just wanted to be done with it so badly,” she said.
When she reported the incident to Bill Velazquez, a manager on the Latino outreach team, he told her, “I bet you would have liked it if he were younger,” according to her account and another woman who witnessed the exchange. Then he laughed.
….
In an interview Wednesday night on CNN, Mr. Sanders said he was proud of his 2016 campaign and attributed any missteps with staff members to the explosive growth that was sometimes overwhelming. “I’m not going to sit here and tell you that we did everything right, in terms of human resources,” he told Anderson Cooper.
“I certainly apologize to any woman who felt she was not treated appropriately, and of course if I run we will do better the next time,” he said.
Asked if he knew about the staff complaints, he said, “I was a little bit busy running around the country trying to make the case.”
No, and no again.
America can find a better opponent to face Trump.
City, Elections, Local Government, School District, Walworth County
Elections, Contested or Uncontested
by JOHN ADAMS •
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 1.3.19
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Thursday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of forty. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:33 PM, for 9h 08m 22s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 5.6% of its visible disk illuminated.
Whitewater’s Fire Department Board of Directors is scheduled to meet at 6:30 PM.
On this day in 1959, Alaska becomes the 49th state.
Recommended for reading in full:
Shawn Johnson reports Evers Planning To Visit Lincoln Hills During His First Week In Office:
Gov.-elect Tony Evers said he’ll visit the troubled Lincoln Hills juvenile prison during his first week in office, a move he said will let people working and serving time there know that he cares about what happens to them.
The visit would stand in sharp contrast to the approach of Gov. Scott Walker, who never visited Lincoln Hills or any other Wisconsin correctional facility during his eight years in office.
Ali Breland writes In 2018, Americans Took a Page From the Russian Disinformation Playbook:
Domestic disinformation and misinformation isn’t new. Outlandish conspiracy theories like Pizzagate went viral before 2018. Infowars, a pivotal progenitor of internet misinformation, has been online since 1999. “What’s new is the technology that makes it easy to set up websites, write dubious stories, modify videos, and spread them through social media, which gives them exposure that’s unprecedented,” explains Alan Rosenblatt, director of digital research at Lake Research Partners and a professor at George Washington University.
Before social media could amplify information in the way it does now, Infowars’ outrageous claims, including one that the 2010 film Machete was a part of a government plot to incite a race war, went relatively unnoticed. Now, hoaxes rip across the internet, leaving wakes big enough to cascade into national discourse.
In 2018, major technology giants finally deplatformed prominent hoax peddlers like Infowars creator Alex Jones, but his impact couldn’t be reversed. Even though he’s no longer on Facebook and Twitter, Jones’ domestic misinformation playbook is still etched into far-right internet circles.
Anne Gearan reports A defensive Trump calls a Cabinet meeting and uses it to boast, deflect and distract:
President Trump, 12 days into a government shutdown and facing new scrutiny from emboldened Democrats, inaugurated the new year Wednesday with a Cabinet meeting. It quickly became a 95-minute stream-of-consciousness defense of his presidency and worldview, filled with falsehoods, revisionist history and self-aggrandizement.
(Ninety-five minutes: now we know how long crushed Adderall can keep a morbidly obese, septuagenarian man going.)
Jennifer Rubin observes Trump doesn’t understand his leverage is gone:
One wondrous result of the 2018 election, we will discover, is the near-total irrelevance of Trump’s tweets. He can say whatever wacky thing he wants, throw out whatever insults he pleases, but Pelosi (D-Calif.), the incoming House speaker, is not going to be thrown off track or even alarmed. She takes his tweets as confirmation he is clueless and unstable.
Laws/Regulations, Litigation, Politics, State Government, Tony Evers, Wisconsin
Evers Turns the Board Around
by JOHN ADAMS •
Tony Evers, by his nature, avoids initiating a confrontation. He seems to have found a political and legal strategy to match his natural disposition. Patrick Marley reports Tony Evers says it will take a lawsuit to get him to go along with lame-duck legislation:
Incoming Gov. Tony Evers said Wednesday he would not go along with parts of lame-duck laws that curb his powers, maintaining that GOP lawmakers or their supporters would have to sue him over the issue.
“I’m anticipating most of the provisions will be challenged and I’m guessing I will be a defendant rather than a plaintiff,” Evers said in an interview Wednesday at his transition office.
The Democrat’s stance changes the dynamic in the fight over the lame-duck legislation by prodding Republicans into initiating litigation instead of doing so himself.
….
Evers likened the situation to attempts by Walker and GOP lawmakers to chip into his authority over state rules as the state schools superintendent. Allies of Evers sued and won before the state Supreme Court the first time Republicans tried to diminish his powers. A second lawsuit over the issue — this one brought by Evers’ opponents — is now before the state’s high court.
“Having gone through this in my previous job as state superintendent, I think it’s more likely that I will be sued because I’m now the chief executive of the state,” Evers said of a potential legal fight over the lame-duck legislation “Same thing happened when I was state superintendent — I was sued. So that’s where I anticipate most of the action to be.”
Politics, Religion
Who Said It Better: Falwell or Christ?
by JOHN ADAMS •
A poor person never gave anyone a job. A poor person never gave anybody charity, not of any real volume. It’s just common sense to me.
— Jerry Falwell Jr. can’t imagine Trump ‘doing anything that’s not good for the country’.
41 He sat down opposite the treasury and observed how the crowd put money into the treasury. Many rich people put in large sums.
42 A poor widow also came and put in two small coins worth a few cents.
43 Calling his disciples to himself, he said to them, “Amen, I say to you, this poor widow put in more than all the other contributors to the treasury.
44 For they have all contributed from their surplus wealth, but she, from her poverty, has contributed all she had, her whole livelihood.”
Falwell, a self-professed evangelical, here speaks in direct opposition to plain Christian teaching. (Indeed, his full interview with the Washington Post reveals error after error, as though Falwell had never seen, let alone read, a New Testament. No doubt he has read one; it’s simply that what he’s saying now is not found in the faith he professes.)
Falwell and his ilk are mistaken if they think those of us who are religious – or candidly anyone who can read a text – will yield to his contrivances.
Assault Awareness & Prevention, CDA, Charity, City, Corporate Welfare, Culture, Dogs, Economy, Education, Federal Government, Foxconn, Free Markets, Government Spending, Innovation Center/Tech Park, Local Government, Police, Politics, School District, State Capitalism, State Government, University, UW System, WEDC, Wisconsin
The Broad Outlines of 2019
by JOHN ADAMS •
For many years, I would begin the year with predictions for the twelve months ahead. Events since 2016 have made predictions harder, but one can still discern some short-term developments for the city. These prospects, of course, form an online of topics to ponder, and about which to write (often requiring that one return to the same topic many times as needed throughout the year). A few general issues for Whitewater appear below, listed alphabetically.
Assault Awareness and Prevention. The campus wants healing, and the city needs enlightenment, but both will come only through a process of truth and reconciliation. Whitewater has slipped closer to Missoula or Steubenville than any town should. Those communities do not have reputation problems — they have had, so to speak, individual injury problems. The latter led to the former.
Community. There are green shoots in this city even in hard times. They’re not to be found at the Whitewater CDA, or city government, but in local organizing efforts (for food, clothing, necessities). These are worthy efforts that will make a difference in residents’ lives. For all the hard problems to address, these are the soft (yet durable) solutions to applaud.
Economy, Local. Whitewater has a weak local economy. See Two Truths of Whitewater’s Economy.
Indeed, she’s gone in the wrong direction (from Wisconsin and America) these last ten years. See Reported Family Poverty in Whitewater Increased Over the Last Decade.
Economy, National. Recession or not, growth will decline enough so that it will feel like a recession for many. See Low Growth as Decline.
Evers. He has a tall order before him, but I think he’ll grow on more and more Wisconsinites.
Print Publications. Putting the expression ‘circling the drain’ to good use.
Schools. The most important work isn’t a referendum; it’s everything afterward.
Town-Gown. Accreditation, coffee, dogs, and shopping (however attractive in the moment) won’t be enough to bridge the gap between campus and the community beyond.
Trumpism. There is no greater threat to an American community than a bigoted, self-dealing authoritarianism that holds federal executive power in its grip.
WEDC, CDA, CIA, FBI, whatever… If there’s ever been a risible failure for Whitewater, it’s the state-capitalist and crony-capitalist approach of the WEDC, and the use of the Whitewater Community Development Authority as a tiny WEDC. Local notables and their out-of-touch appointee playing venture capitalist with public money isn’t venture capitalism, or any kind of productive free-market approach. It’s a vanity project that short-changes the community. Pride makes for poor policy.
For all these that one can see, there will be other issues that emerge over the year.
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 1.2.19
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Wednesday in Whitewater will see cloudy skies and a high of twenty-nine. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:32 PM, for 9h 07m 26s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 11% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1918, Wisconsin troops depart for Europe:
the Wisconsin 127th and 128th Infantries departed for France from their training facility at Camp Arthur in Waco, Texas. Initially, these divisions were assigned to construct depots and facilities for troops that would follow. On May 18, they were assigned to the frontline at Belmont in the Alsace where they faced three German divisions. In the following months, 368 troops were killed, wounded or missing. Ironically, their enemy, native Alsatians, spoke German and the Wisconsin troops were better able to communicate with them than their French allies.
Recommended for reading in full:
Patrick Marley reports Scott Walker to join speaker’s bureau, emphasize tax cuts and help re-elect Donald Trump:
Departing Gov. Scott Walker told supporters Tuesday he would be giving speeches, emphasizing tax cuts and working to re-elect President Donald Trump after Walker leaves office next week.
(Putting that charisma and dynamic speaking style to good use already…)
Brad Reed reports Trump-loving economist [Stephen Moore] caught red-handed ‘making up numbers’ by CNN guest [Catherine Rampell]:
“Both of the rate hikes were unnecessary and were a cause for deflation in the economy,” he [Moore] said.
“Wait, wait, wait!” interjected Rampell. “There is no deflation!”
“Yeah there is,” Moore replied.
“No there is not,” she shot back. “Look at the Consumer Price Index!”
Moore tried to counter by noting that some prices on the Commodities Price Index had dropped — but Rampell hit back by saying that much of that was due to President Donald Trump’s trade wars.
“Soy bean prices are falling because of the trade war,” she said.
Rampell then nailed Moore for his false warnings during the Obama presidency that it was unwise for the Fed to keep interest rates low because it would lead to hyperinflation — despite the fact that the economy at the time was deeply depressed and much more in need of easy money.
Catherine Rampell writes elsewhere A recession is coming. Trump will make it so much worse:
Statistically speaking, given how long the economy has been growing, a recession is overdue — and the eventual collapse may bear Trump’s fingerprints. After all, his new trade barriers have lifted manufacturing costs, closed off markets and clouded the future for American firms with global supply chains. Economists say Trump’s trade war is the biggest threat to the U.S. economy in 2019. In loonier moments, the president has also threatened to default on our debt, ramp up the money-printing press, reinstate the gold standard or deport all 11 million undocumented immigrants. Some of those policies would ignite not just a recession but an immediate, global financial crisis.
How This Dummy-Car Tests Collision Detection Systems In Your Car:
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 1.1.19
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Tuesday begins a new year in Whitewater with cloudy skies and a high of twenty-five. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:32 PM, for 9h 06m 34s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 18.4% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1863, the Emancipation Proclamation takes effect.
Recommended for reading in full:
Patrick Marley reports Speaker Robin Vos won’t release $850,000 contract with law firm in Wisconsin gerrymandering case:
MADISON – Assembly Speaker Robin Vos won’t make public a legal contract that will cost taxpayers $850,000, despite a state law meant to ensure government records are widely available.
Advocates for open records say the Rochester Republican is in the wrong and must release a copy of the contract with the Chicago-based law firm Bartlit Beck.
Assembly Republicans recently retained the firm to help defend the state in a long-running lawsuit over legislative district lines they drew in 2011 that have helped them win elections. Taxpayers have already spent more than $2 million in legal fees to draw and defend those maps.
“They should just release the record. I mean, it’s clearly a public record and it should be automatic,” said Orville Seymer, field operations director of the conservative Citizens for Responsible Government and a member of the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council’s board.
“I think the denial of this contract is clearly illegal and clearly in bad faith,” said Bill Lueders, editor of The Progressive magazine and president of the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council.
Later in the story, Marley quotes Rick Esenberg, president of the conservative Wisconsin Institute of Law & Liberty, as saying “They have got a lot of law on their side,” Esenberg said of the stance Vos’ team has taken.” Oh, brother – they only have ‘a lot of law’ on their side if one assumes that an entire contract with a public body, itself, constitutes an attorney-client writing. It most certainly does not, as Esenberg surely knows.
April Barker, a Brookfield attorney and a vice president of the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council, said it is unusual for legal contracts to include information that is subject to attorney-client privilege. Lawyers are careful in how they write them because they know that such contracts must sometimes be released as part of litigation, she said.
If the contract does include any privileged information, Vos should black out those portions of the contract and release the remainder of it, she said.
“I can’t see any legitimate basis for withholding the entire document,” she said.
Jennifer Rubin observes Trump’s agenda is dependent on provable falsehoods:
Trump’s lies are not inconsequential. They are a necessary foundation for his political survival (in an investigation that has indicted more than 30 people, he still screams “Witch hunt!”) and for an agenda that is based on ignorance and deception. And because of the centrality of lying to his survival and agenda, Republicans who continue to support him increasingly must live alongside him in his alternative universe.
Music
Monday Music: Bobby Timmons Trio, Auld Lang Syne
by JOHN ADAMS •
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 12.31.18
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Monday in Whitewater will be cloudy with a high of thirty-six. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:31 PM, for 9h 05m 45s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 27.2% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1879, Thomas Edison conducts a public demonstration of his incandescent bulb:
Other people had been working on the making of light bulbs in the past, but none of the earlier bulbs was ever able to work for more than a few minutes. Finally, on October 21, 1879, Edison’s light bulb burned for a continuous thirteen and a half hours. The following bulbs lasted for 40 hours and Edison and his team worked hard to light the laboratory and his home with several of the new light bulbs for Christmas. On New Year’s Eve of the same year, Christie Street became the world’s first street to be lit by incandescent light bulbs with the help of a power system designed by Edison. By the summer of 1880, Edison had perfected the incandescent bulb enough to be able to produce and sell it in large quantities.
Recommended for reading in full:
Alexandra Alter reports New Life for Old Classics, as Their Copyrights Run Out:
This coming year marks the first time in two decades that a large body of copyrighted works will lose their protected status — a shift that will have profound consequences for publishers and literary estates, which stand to lose both money and creative control.
But it will also be a boon for readers, who will have more editions to choose from, and for writers and other artists who can create new works based on classic stories without getting hit with an intellectual property lawsuit.
“Books are going to be available in a much wider variety now, and they’re going to be cheaper,” said Imke Reimers, an assistant professor of economics at Northeastern University who has studied the impact of copyright. “Consumers and readers are definitely going to benefit from this.”
The sudden deluge of available works traces back to legislation Congress passed in 1998, which extended copyright protections by 20 years. The law reset the copyright term for works published from 1923 to 1977 — lengthening it from 75 years to 95 years after publication — essentially freezing their protected status. (The law is often referred to by skeptics as the “Mickey Mouse Protection Act,” since it has kept “Steamboat Willie,” the first Disney film featuring Mickey, under copyright until 2024.)
Now that the term extension has run out, the spigot has been turned back on. Each January will bring a fresh crop of novels, plays, music and movies into the public domain. Over the next few years, the impact will be particularly dramatic, in part because the 1920s were such a fertile and experimental period for Western literature, with the rise of masters like F. Scott Fitzgerald, William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway and Virginia Woolf.
This Abandoned Nuclear City is Trapped Under Ice, What Happens if it Thaws?
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 12.30.18
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Sunday in Whitewater will be mostly sunny with a high of thirty-six. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:30 PM, for 9h 05m 01s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 37.1% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1922, authorities in Madison confiscate illegal alcohol: “1,200 gallons of “mash” and fifteen gallons of moonshine from the home of a suspected bootlegger.”
Recommended for reading in full:
Linda Qui writes Deciphering the Patterns in Trump’s Falsehoods:
Fact checkers have compiled lists of all of Mr. Trump’s falsehoods since he took office (The Washington Post counts over 7,500, and The Toronto Star over 3,900), rounded up his most egregious whoppers in year-end lists and scrutinized his claims in real time with television chyrons.
Repetition and Inflation
Mr. Trump refuses to correct most of his inaccurate claims, instead asserting them over and over again. They become, by sheer force of repetition, “alternative facts” and staples of his campaign rallies and speeches.
Examples abound. He has falsely characterized the December 2017 tax cuts as the “largest” or the “biggest” in American history over 100 times (several others were larger). He has misleadingly said over 90 times that his promised wall along the southern border is being built (construction has not begun on any new section). He has falsely accused Democrats of supporting “open borders” over 60 times (Democratic lawmakers support border security, but not his border wall). And he has lobbed over 250 inaccurate attacks on the investigation into Russian election interference.
….
Shifting and Deflecting
In the face of controversy or criticism, Mr. Trump has defended initial falsehoods with additional dubious claims.
This approach is evident in his shifting statements about the payment that Michael D. Cohen, his former lawyer, made to a pornographic film actress to keep her from speaking about their alleged affair. In April, Mr. Trump falsely denied knowing about the payment.
After the F.B.I. raided Mr. Cohen’s office, Mr. Trump acknowledged on Twitter in May that Mr. Cohen received reimbursement for the payment and asserted that it had nothing to do with his presidential campaign. Mr. Cohen would later tell prosecutors that he acted at Mr. Trump’s direction and to influence the election.
….
Misleading Vagueness and Fanciful Details
Mr. Trump also regales his audience with elaborate stories. Some — like his tales of unnamed “strong” or “tough” men, miners or steelworkers crying and thanking him — may have occurred but are impossible to verify.
….
Inventing Straw Men
The usual target of this particular strain of falsehoods is the news media, which Mr. Trump suggests purposely underestimates or misinterprets him.
Mr. Trump often lauds strong job growth under his watch and says that the “fake news” would have deemed such numbers “impossible” or “ridiculous” during the 2016 campaign. Yet he neglects to mention that the number of jobs added in the 22 months after his inauguration — 4.2 million — is lower than the 4.8 million jobs added in the 22 months before he took office, undermining the premise of his retrodiction.
Daily Bread
Daily Bread for 12.29.18
by JOHN ADAMS •
Good morning.
Saturday in Whitewater will be mostly cloudy with a high of twenty-nine. Sunrise is 7:25 AM and sunset 4:29 PM, for 9h 04m 21s of daytime. The moon is a waning crescent with 47.7% of its visible disk illuminated.
On this day in 1879, General William “Billy” Mitchell is born.
Recommended for reading in full:
Patrick Radden Keefe explains How Mark Burnett Resurrected Donald Trump as an Icon of American Success (“With “The Apprentice,” the TV producer mythologized Trump—then a floundering D-lister—as the ultimate titan, paving his way to the Presidency”):
In 2002, Burnett rented Wollman Rink, in Central Park, for a live broadcast of the Season 4 finale of “Survivor.” The property was controlled by Donald Trump, who had obtained the lease to operate the rink in 1986, and had plastered his name on it. Before the segment started, Burnett addressed fifteen hundred spectators who had been corralled for the occasion, and noticed Trump sitting with Melania Knauss, then his girlfriend, in the front row. Burnett prides himself on his ability to “read the room”: to size up the personalities in his audience, suss out what they want, and then give it to them.
“I need to show respect to Mr. Trump,” Burnett recounted, in a 2013 speech in Vancouver. “I said, ‘Welcome, everybody, to Trump Wollman skating rink. The Trump Wollman skating rink is a fine facility, built by Mr. Donald Trump. Thank you, Mr. Trump. Because the Trump Wollman skating rink is the place we are tonight and we love being at the Trump Wollman skating rink, Mr. Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump.” As Burnett told the story, he had scarcely got offstage before Trump was shaking his hand, proclaiming, “You’re a genius!”
Max Fisher reports Inside Facebook’s Secret Rulebook for Global Political Speech (“Under fire for stirring up distrust and violence, the social network has vowed to police its users. But leaked documents raise serious questions about its approach”):
Every other Tuesday morning, several dozen Facebook employees gather over breakfast to come up with the rules, hashing out what the site’s two billion users should be allowed to say. The guidelines that emerge from these meetings are sent out to 7,500-plus moderators around the world. (After publication of this article, Facebook said it had increased that number to around 15,000.)
The closely held rules are extensive, and they make the company a far more powerful arbiter of global speech than has been publicly recognized or acknowledged by the company itself, The New York Times has found.
The Times was provided with more than 1,400 pages from the rulebooks by an employee who said he feared that the company was exercising too much power, with too little oversight — and making too many mistakes.
An examination of the files revealed numerous gaps, biases and outright errors. As Facebook employees grope for the right answers, they have allowed extremist language to flourish in some countries while censoring mainstream speech in others.

